Earth May Have Formed Entirely From Inner Solar System Material
By @sharedot · · 6 pages
- Science
- Space
- Planetary Science
A new ETH Zurich isotope study suggests Earth built itself from a single inner Solar System reservoir, overturning the long-held idea of water-rich material from beyond Jupiter.
What the new study claims
A study by planetary scientists Paolo Sossi and Dan Bower of ETH Zurich, published in Nature Astronomy, concludes that the material that formed Earth came entirely from the inner Solar System.
According to the researchers, material from beyond Jupiter accounts for less than two percent of Earth's total mass, and possibly none at all. "Our calculations make it clear: the building material of the Earth originates from a single material reservoir," Sossi says.
Bower adds that the team was "truly astonished" to find Earth composed of material distinct from any combination of existing meteorites.
Why it overturns the old picture
For years, scientists proposed that 6 to 40 percent of Earth's building material arrived from the outer Solar System beyond Jupiter, a key part of explaining how the planet acquired volatile substances such as water.
The new analysis finds no evidence for the previously proposed exchange of material between the inner and outer reservoirs.
It instead suggests Jupiter acted as an effective gravitational barrier, carving a gap in the protoplanetary disc and limiting how much outer material ever reached the region where Earth formed.
How the team reached the result
The researchers compared isotope ratios from a wide range of meteorites, including samples associated with Mars and the asteroid Vesta, with Earth's isotopic composition.
Earlier studies typically relied on only two isotope systems, mainly oxygen isotopes, but this work drew on measurements from ten different isotope systems, including chromium and titanium, which can reveal where meteorites formed.
According to ScienceDaily, Sossi described the work as "data science experiments" using statistical calculations rarely applied in geochemistry. The results also show Earth's composition resembles that of Mars and Vesta.
A new water mystery and next steps
The findings raise a major new question: if Earth received little water-rich material from the outer Solar System, scientists must explain how enough water could have existed in the hot inner Solar System to eventually produce Earth's oceans.
Sossi and his team plan to investigate that next, and also want to determine whether similar processes could occur in planetary systems around other stars.
According to the researchers, Mercury and Venus may fit the same pattern as Earth, Mars, and Vesta, though that prediction cannot yet be tested because no rock samples exist from either planet. Sossi notes the scientific discourse is far from over despite the new findings.