DOJ Moves to Kick Two Minnesota Judges Off Immigration Cases

The DOJ moved to disqualify Minnesota Judges Patrick Schiltz and John Tunheim from immigration cases after they criticized Operation Metro Surge.

@sharedot

DOJ Moves to Kick Two Minnesota Judges Off Immigration Cases

By @sharedot · · 6 pages

  • US News
  • Immigration
  • Judiciary
  • Minnesota

The DOJ moved to disqualify Minnesota Judges Patrick Schiltz and John Tunheim from immigration cases after they criticized Operation Metro Surge.

DOJ asks two Minnesota judges to step aside

The Justice Department has filed separate recusal motions seeking to disqualify two Minnesota federal judges from high-profile immigration cases because of their public comments about the Trump administration's enforcement push.

One motion targets Senior U.S. District Judge Patrick Schiltz, who is overseeing DOJ's effort to strip U.S. citizenship from Salah Osman Ahmed, a Somali American man who pleaded guilty in 2009 to providing material support to terrorists.

Both judges were quoted in a September 17 New York Times story about Operation Metro Surge, the administration's wintertime immigration operation in Minneapolis, and DOJ argues their participation in what it calls a 'highly partisan' article calls their impartiality into doubt.

Judges publicly attacked the operation they now oversee

What makes the motions remarkable is that the two judges are being asked to decide their own impartiality in cases tied to the very operation they criticized in print.

Schiltz sat for a roughly 90-minute Times interview in which he described the administration's handling of Metro Surge as creating a 'grave threat to the rule of law,' and told the Times that ICE's violation of hundreds of court orders threatened the rule of law, warning that without it 'you have either anarchy or you have authoritarianism.'

Tunheim told the newspaper that agents carrying out the crackdown were not, in his view, primarily arresting dangerous criminals.

Schiltz has rejected any basis for recusal, saying he has never commented on the merits of a particular case and citing a February advisory opinion from the Committee on Codes of Conduct confirming that federal judges may speak on core judiciary matters such as advocacy for the rule of law and judicial independence.

Part of a broader pressure campaign on the bench

The recusal motions escalate a dispute that began last month, when DOJ filed a judicial misconduct complaint against Schiltz, Tunheim and five of their Minnesota colleagues who participated in the Times report, asking the Eighth Circuit to investigate.

Attorney General Todd Blanche said their conduct had 'undermined public confidence in an impartial judiciary in Minnesota.'

The underlying Times story revealed the judges regularly met, communicated through running email threads and used an informal spreadsheet to consult one another on recurring legal questions, though Chief Judge Eric Tostrud told Fox News Digital that each judge independently decided every case assigned to them.

Charles 'Cully' Stimson, a senior legal fellow at the Heritage Foundation, told Fox News Digital the judges did something 'extraordinarily imprudent' by speaking to any newspaper, and said he would recuse himself if the Times interview were the only fact at issue.

Schiltz has continued speaking out, repeating his criticisms at a University of St. Thomas law symposium days after the ethics complaint.

What happens next for the cases and the court

Each judge will decide the recusal motion against himself, St. Thomas law professor Greg Sisk told MPR News. If either refuses to step aside, the Justice Department could ask other district judges to rule, but Sisk said the law makes it difficult to get an appeals court to force a judge off a case.

He suggested the motions may be aimed largely at sending a message to other federal judges that public criticism of the administration's DOJ will draw recusal challenges.

Schiltz told MPR News he cannot comment on the ethics complaint because the Eighth Circuit proceedings are confidential, and Tunheim did not respond to Fox News Digital's request for comment.

Ahmed's attorney, Minneapolis lawyer Daniel Gerdts, called the recusal arguments 'contrived and baseless,' saying he has occasionally disagreed with Schiltz's decisions but never questioned his impartiality.

A DOJ spokesperson also declined to say whether the department would appeal if either judge denies the motion.

Sources

  1. foxnews.com › DOJ moves to boot two federal judges from immigration cases over remarks to media: 'Extraordinarily imprudent'
  2. mprnews.org › Feds seek to boot Minnesota judges from immigration cases after public comments

More on US News