Israeli Restaurants Boom in New York Despite Backlash
By @sharedot · · 6 pages
- Food
- Israeli Restaurants
- Nyc Dining
- Michelin Star
Haaretz and Ynetnews report Israeli restaurants in New York are drawing long lines and A-list diners even as others lose customers to backlash.
A Split Table: Backlash and Blockbuster Lines
Two Israeli outlets painting the same New York dining scene this week describe a strikingly divided picture.
The piece opens with chef Eli Buliskeria — behind Bustan on the Upper West Side and Mesiba in Williamsburg — having left New York a few months ago to work as a private chef for a wealthy family in Palo Alto whose name he cannot reveal.
Ynetnews frames the trend the opposite way: not even antisemitism and boycott calls have stopped Israeli chefs in the United States, and the most prominent restaurants openly advertise their identity with Hebrew or distinctly Israeli names such as Miznon, Malka, Shmoné, Or'esh, Motek, Carmel and the Yiddish Balaboosta.
The Standout: A First Michelin Star for Kosher
According to Ynetnews, the clearest proof that good food can outlast the loudest protests came in North Miami, where chef Raz Shabtai's kosher restaurant Motra in May became the first kosher restaurant in the world to receive a Michelin star — an achievement the outlet calls extraordinary for a kosher establishment.
Ynetnews credits diners and critics alike: American diners, including celebrities, are not especially concerned with what Mark Ruffalo or Javier Bardem think about Israel, and as long as the food is good and critics praise it, they will come.
The outlet notes most critics do not rush to bring politics onto the plate.
In New York, chef Nadav Greenberg of Or'esh — who earned a Michelin star with Eyal Shani's team at Shmoné before opening his charcoal-focused Manhattan restaurant in February — tells Ynetnews that even with a Hebrew name, mezuzahs at the entrance and his face, the restaurant is among the hottest in the city, succeeding not just on hype but on returning customers.
Appropriation Fight and Signature Dishes
Ynetnews reports that not everyone is celebrating the success of Israeli cuisine, which has repeatedly been accused of cultural appropriation.
The outlet says New York Magazine published an article in August arguing that Israeli chefs take Middle Eastern, Arab, Palestinian and North African dishes and market them to American diners as fashionable, sophisticated and expensive Israeli cuisine — a framing Ynetnews disputes, arguing many chefs have also created original recipes combining ingredients in unconventional ways.
The chefs' signature dishes show the range Ynetnews describes: Greenberg serves a potato pastel with caviar and a dramatic whole tuna plate, built on charcoal cooking he says Americans rarely do.
In Los Angeles, Asaf 'Assi' Maoz of Carmel tells Ynetnews his Jerusalem artichoke tortellini with house-made miso comes from his Italian grandmother, while his Syrian grandmother taught him the mushroom cigar filling — and Hollywood regulars including LeBron James, Sofia Vergara, Sydney Sweeney and Charlize Theron keep coming back.
Pioneers, Regrets and What Comes Next
Haaretz also spotlights survival dishes, noting that one popular dish at Shifka is a Tunisian sandwich served in malawach, inspired by corner-store sandwiches in Be'er Sheva.
Meanwhile, Ynetnews profiles Einat Admony, among the first chefs to make Israeli food part of New York's scene: she opened Taim in 2005 as a small East Village falafel shop, followed by Balaboosta in 2010, and remembers Robin Williams playing with her son while waiting for falafel.
She tells Ynetnews she regrets Taim's expansion, saying the partners brought in bad people who pushed the founders out and destroyed the chain — she sold most of her shares four years ago and now reaches diners nationwide through the CookUnity meal-delivery service.
The stakes going forward, per both outlets' reporting, are whether momentum can hold: Haaretz documents chefs exiting the city for private work while others pack dining rooms, and Ynetnews argues good food and critical praise are proving to outweigh boycott calls.
For now, the niche's defining story is that Israeli food's hottest tables are busier than ever in a hostile climate.