Mackinac Island Wins Best Fall Destination Again
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- Travel
- Mackinac Island
- Fall Foliage
- USA Today 10best
Mackinac Island has been named America's No. 1 fall destination for the second straight year in the 2026 USA TODAY 10Best Readers' Choice Awards.
A Back-to-Back National Title
Mackinac Island has been named the No. 1 Best Place to Visit for Fall in the United States in the 2026 USA TODAY 10Best Readers' Choice Awards, and it is a repeat: the island also won the honor in 2025, making it America's top fall destination two years running.
Patch reports the island again beat out famously autumnal competitors including Sleepy Hollow, New York; Burlington, Vermont; and Gatlinburg, Tennessee.
Multiple outlets note the island also claimed the No. 1 Best Summer Travel Destination title from USA TODAY 10Best earlier this year, making 2026 a double-header. The awards are decided by reader voting after a panel of travel experts nominates the destinations.
Why the Judges and Voters Picked It
USA TODAY 10Best highlighted what it called the island's perfectly tuned fall vibes: 'Crisp, sunny days with vibrant foliage give way to a slower pace of life in this resort town,' according to Patch's coverage of the citation.
The publication pointed to horse-drawn carriage rides as one of the best ways to see the island's colors, along with trick-or-treating at downtown shops over Halloween weekend, fall decor, and scenic bike rides.
Nomad Lawyer attributes the island's appeal to its ban on private motor vehicles, which creates a carriage-and-bicycle 'time-capsule' experience aligned with slower, experience-based travel trends.
Michigan's Broader Fall Sweep
Mackinac was not Michigan's only win. boston.com reports that the Upper Peninsula took the No. 1 spot for fall colors in the same 10Best awards, beating every New England contender; the White Mountains ranked No. 8 and the Berkshires No. 10 on that list.
Nomad Lawyer says the Upper Peninsula's roughly 7 million acres of forest and about 1,500 miles of designated fall color routes drive its drawing power.
Burlington, Vermont was also named a top-ten fall destination by readers, and Portsmouth, New Hampshire placed No. 3 in a separate LateRooms study of America's coziest small towns for autumn, scoring 76.18 with a downtown Walk Score of 97, per WOKQ.
Fudge, Festivals and a Full Calendar
Patch reports the island will host its Fall Fudge Festival on October 2-3, with downtown streets lined in fall decor.
The festival weekend overlaps other seasonal draws: boston.com notes the Freeport Fall Festival in Maine runs October 2-4 and ranked No. 3 among America's fall festivals, while the Berkshires' foliage parade — running since 1956 — holds its 70th edition on October 4.
Burlington's season, per boston.com, opens in September with the South End Art Hop featuring more than 500 artists in over 100 venues, plus waterfront Oktoberfest.
The Stakes: Demand, Bookings and Pressure
Nomad Lawyer argues the awards translate into practical pressure for travelers: expect hotels and short-term rentals in the Upper Peninsula and on Mackinac Island to fill faster than in previous years, with accommodations needing to be booked well ahead of the peak color window.
It also flags that the island's car-free rules mean slower transit — budget more time to cross the island on foot, bike or carriage.
The same analysis says the shoulder-season influx is an economic bridge for rural communities but brings environmental strain, with Michigan authorities emphasizing staying on marked trails and managing traffic on the UP's scenic routes.
What Comes Next for Foliage Season
The foliage window in Michigan typically runs from late September through October depending on latitude and elevation, according to Nomad Lawyer, which recommends monitoring local forestry reports and the UP's designated color routes to time a visit.
On the island, expect the Halloween weekend program — kids trick-or-treating at downtown shops and adult costume parties — to cap the season, as highlighted in the 10Best citation.
Sources
- wcrz.com › Mackinac Island Just Won America's Best Fall Destination Again
- patch.com › MI Travel Destination Earns Top Spot For Best Fall Place In The Nation Again
- nomadlawyer.org › Michigan Travel Boom: Upper Peninsula and Mackinac Island Lead America's Fall Tourism Rankings
- boston.com › 4 of the best destinations in America for fall foliage and fun are in New England
- wokq.com › National Study Ranks Portsmouth, NH Third Coziest Small Town For Autumn