Trump Calls Deportation Policy 'Too Tough' After Midterms
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- US News
- Immigration
- Trump
- Midterms
In a 60 Minutes interview after GOP midterm losses, Trump conceded his deportation drive was too tough and offered Democrats an immigration deal.
What happened: an unusual admission
President Donald Trump told CBS's 60 Minutes, in his first television interview since Republicans lost both chambers of Congress in last week's midterms, that his deportation policy may have gone too far.
Asked by correspondent Ross Douthat whether the crackdown had gone too far, he replied: "I think it was too tough. I think it might be too tough, yeah."
He acknowledged the aggressive ICE enforcement campaign had "both helped and hurt" him politically, saying he earned "very high marks for getting the bad ones out" but was hurt because the government "also took people that had good jobs" whose only violation was entering the country illegally.
Why the reversal is striking
The concession came just days after Trump elevated Stephen Miller, the chief architect of the hardline immigration crackdown, to White House chief of staff, replacing Susie Wiles — a move that seemed at odds with any softening.
Senate Democratic leader Chuck Schumer seized on the contradiction on X, writing that Trump's solution to the crackdown going too far "was to put the man responsible for it in charge of the White House. That's not a course correction. That's a promotion."
The admission is an unusually frank acknowledgment that a defining policy of the second administration had become a political liability.
The evidence: Latino voters shifted hard
The political damage was measurable. The New York Post reports that just one in three Hispanic voters said they cast their ballot for a Republican in their US House race, according to The AP Voter Poll of more than 100,000 midterm voters — down from roughly four in ten who backed Trump in 2024.
Democrats won control of both the House and Senate, and in battleground states with large Latino populations like Texas they captured governorships and Senate seats.
Commentator Samantha Karlin told the Post that there is "a profound difference between supporting border security and watching people who look like you, your family, and your neighbors being targeted by aggressive immigration enforcement."
The offer: a deal with Democrats
Trump floated an immigration agreement with the new Democratic-controlled Congress, saying "the deal would be we would work something out" and calling it "something that's actually doable."
He proposed allowing long-term undocumented residents who have lived and worked in the country for 10 or 15 years, paying taxes, to stay, while continuing to remove people convicted of serious crimes such as killers, rapists and drug dealers.
He claimed some Democrats had already contacted him and said he could easily refrain from name-calling for six months to secure an agreement. Democrats have said oversight of ICE and the Department of Homeland Security is a priority for the new Congress.
The stakes for the policy
Since Trump returned to office, sweeping ICE raids at workplaces, homes and public spaces have ensnared people with no criminal records, separated families and spread fear in immigrant communities.
Federal agents fatally shot two US citizens, Renee Good and Alex Pretti, during operations in Minneapolis this year.
The New York Post notes Republicans lost the Hispanic vote last Tuesday, while Trump defended his border record, giving himself "an A+ for closing up the border" and claiming zero people crossed the southern border in 17 months.
The question now is whether a Trump concession can outlast the promotion of the policy's architect.
What comes next
The interview covered ground well beyond immigration. Trump blamed the war with Iran and higher petrol prices for the midterm defeat, echoing JD Vance's assessment, while insisting the campaign was justified and that a renewed assault on Iran is "highly unlikely."
On the economy he conceded "bad messaging, maybe by me," and he signaled openness to AI "guardrails."
Forbes senior editor Dan Alexander challenged Trump's claim that a $3bn wealth increase reflected stock market gains, attributing it instead to crypto ventures generating more than $1bn in proceeds, overseas licensing, and the removal of a nearly $500m New York penalty.
Whether the immigration offer leads to negotiations with Democrats remains to be seen.
Sources
- theguardian.com › Trump admits deportation policy was 'too tough' despite promotion of Stephen Miller
- aljazeera.com › Trump says his immigration policy 'too tough' for voters
- nypost.com › Trump backs away from hardline immigration policy after midterms blowout
- aol.com › Trump says 'too tough' deportation policies hurt him in the midterms