Critics Hail Cregger's 'Resident Evil' as Best Game Film

First reviews say Zach Cregger's 'Resident Evil' reboot is the franchise's best movie and one of the greatest video game adaptations ever made.

@sharedot

Critics Hail Cregger's 'Resident Evil' as Best Game Film

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • Film
  • Resident Evil
  • Video Game Adaptations
  • Movie Reviews

First reviews say Zach Cregger's 'Resident Evil' reboot is the franchise's best movie and one of the greatest video game adaptations ever made.

What Critics Are Saying

Rotten Tomatoes' review roundup reports that critics are calling the horror reboot not just the best 'Resident Evil' movie ever, but one of the best video game adaptations of all time.

Rotten Tomatoes notes the film, co-written and directed by the 'Weapons' filmmaker and starring Austin Abrams, Zach Cherry and Kali Reis, opens in theaters this weekend.

Matt Goldberg of Decoding Everything, quoted by Rotten Tomatoes, calls it 'one of the best video game movies ever made,' while Julian Roman of MovieWeb says it is 'easily the best Resident Evil film in the franchise.'

Why This Is a Franchise Reversal

The surprise is the reversal. The 'Resident Evil' film series has been a punching bag for critics for two decades, and Rotten Tomatoes' roundup shows reviewers explicitly framing Cregger's take against that history.

The Hollywood Reporter's Frank Scheck, quoted in the roundup, says the filmmaker has 'completely rejuvenated the series, leaving the six original films and the misbegotten reboot attempt Resident Evil: Welcome to Raccoon City in the dust.'

IndieWire's David Ehrlich, also cited by Rotten Tomatoes, goes further, arguing the film 'actually — and rather viscerally — evokes what it feels like to play Resident Evil.'

Vulture's weekend watch column similarly features the film as its marquee movie pick, with Austin Abrams 'fantastic as the bumbling protagonist' in a blend of humor, gore and scares.

The Evidence: Scares, Monsters, Momentum

The praise rests on specifics. Rotten Tomatoes' roundup of critics highlights a briskly paced, breathless 90-minute runtime, with The Hollywood Reporter calling it 'refreshingly fat-free.'

The horror is landing too: IndieWire calls the monsters 'some of the grossest monsters you'll ever see on screen,' and Rotten Tomatoes quotes reviewers praising Legacy Effects' 2,000-pound monster puppets.

Dariusz Wolski's cinematography, several critics told Rotten Tomatoes, emulates the third-person framing of the games.

The humor divides the room — Next Best Picture's Josh Parham told Rotten Tomatoes the comedy 'can often undercut the impact of the horror' — but most critics quoted there call it escapist fun that honors the games' spirit, if not their exact mythology.

The Fan Divide on Faithfulness

Not everyone in the roundup is fully won over.

Rotten Tomatoes notes that purists 'may still yearn for a more faithful adaptation,' and Pickety Witch's Amelia Emberwing told the outlet that the T-Virus is never once mentioned in the film, leaving it unclear whether the monsters are even victims of it.

A Crowded Weekend for Movie Fans

The reboot arrives into a busy weekend that Vulture frames with a joke: 'the two genders this weekend' are 'Barbie in the Nutcracker and Resident Evil,' and the outlet calls both 'fantastic' and 'fun.'

Rotten Tomatoes notes the film is already being ranked by critics alongside 'Sonic the Hedgehog 3' as among the best live-action video game movies ever, per Lisa Laman of Land of the Nerds in the roundup.

For a genre long treated as a punchline — Decoding Everything, via Rotten Tomatoes, says adapting a game 'can't simply be a series of references' — that consensus is itself the story fans are talking about.

What Comes Next

If the reviews hold, the stakes extend well beyond one movie. Critics quoted by Rotten Tomatoes hope other studios let filmmakers 'expand a property instead of another soulless copy-and-paste job,' positioning Cregger's film as a template for game adaptations rather than a one-off win.

With the film opening in theaters this weekend, per Rotten Tomatoes and Vulture, the box office and audience reaction will now test whether reviewers and fans agree.

For 'Resident Evil' devotees, the question shifts from whether a good adaptation is possible to whether Hollywood can keep repeating this playbook.

Sources

  1. editorial.rottentomatoes.com › Resident Evil First Reviews: Not Just the Best Resident Evil Movie, but One of the Best Video Game Movies Ever
  2. vulture.com › The 12 Best Movies and TV Shows to Watch This Weekend

More on Film