Lemurs and Sopranos: 74 Million Years of Convergent Singing
By @sharedot · · 6 pages
- Singing
- Vocal Technique
- Indri
- Formant Tuning
- Convergent Evolution
Outlets report the indri's mouth-opening technique likely arose via convergent evolution, an opera-like solution humans and lemurs found independently.
The new twist: a technique shared across deep time
Syndicated reports from Talker by Stephen Beech, carried by Albia Newspapers and The Pryor Information Publication, add an evolutionary framing to the indri story that goes beyond the frame-by-frame mouth tracking itself.
According to those reports, study first author Filippo Carugati of the University of Turin says humans and indris last shared a common ancestor around 74 million years ago — meaning the similarities in vocal production are likely the result of convergent evolution, the same solution arrived at independently across deep evolutionary time.
In other words, a wet-nosed primate in Madagascar's rainforest canopy and a trained soprano in an opera house have separately settled on the same physical trick for projecting high notes.
Why singers should find this striking
Human singers are trained to widen their mouths as pitch rises, aligning the resonant frequencies of the vocal tract with the harmonics of the voice and amplifying the sound — a process the outlets describe as formant tuning.
The surprise is that the indri appears to do the same thing with no training at all. For an animal communicating through thick forest, researchers say, formant tuning could make the difference between a song that carries across vast distances and one that does not.
Indris sing to strengthen bonds within their social group and to warn neighboring groups to keep their distance, so projection is not decorative — it is the entire point of the performance.
The evidence: 83 videos, 19 lemurs, frame by frame
The research team analyzed 83 video recordings of 19 wild indris, combining field audio with markerless motion-tracking technology, according to the reports.
They tracked upper and lower lip position frame by frame, comparing changes in mouth opening with changes in vocal frequency, and found the indris opened their mouths wider to project higher-pitched vocalizations through the forest.
The study, published in the journal PLOS Computational Biology, is described as the first direct evidence that wild indris coordinate their mouth opening with the frequency of their songs.
Carugati told the outlets that markerless pose estimation let the team study how the face and mouth move while an animal is singing and connect those movements directly to changes in pitch — something that, in his words, you simply cannot capture by listening to the audio alone.
What the researchers say it means
Corresponding author Chiara De Gregorio, an honorary research fellow at the University of Warwick, told the outlets that every time the pitch of an indri's song rose, the team could see its mouth opening wider, frame by frame.
She described it as the kind of fine-tuned coordination between voice and body usually associated with trained human singers, not with a lemur singing from the forest canopy.
For vocal enthusiasts, the implication is provocative: the mechanics taught in studios and conservatories — open the mouth as the pitch climbs so the sound carries — may be a biological constant rather than a cultural invention, refined independently by two branches of the mammal family tree separated by 74 million years of evolution.