Netflix Cancels Sweet Magnolias, Picks Ladies of the House
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- AI Frontier
- Streaming
- Television
Netflix canceled Sweet Magnolias after five seasons and greenlit Sheryl J. Anderson and JoAnna Garcia Swisher's new winery drama Ladies of the House.
What Happened: A Cancellation and a Greenlight in One Move
Netflix canceled its romantic drama *Sweet Magnolias*, starring JoAnna Garcia Swisher, Brooke Elliott and Heather Headley, after five seasons, and at the same time greenlit a new drama series from the show's executive producer and showrunner Sheryl J. Anderson, *Ladies of the House*.
According to Deadline, the decision came down to whether to renew *Sweet Magnolias* for a sixth and final season or order the new series, with Anderson and Swisher shifting their attention to the new show — and Netflix went with the second option.
Variety confirms the pairing, reporting that Anderson will serve as showrunner of *Ladies of the House*, with Swisher set to executive produce and eyed to star alongside Kate Gordon under their Rolling Clover banner, with Black Label Media also executive producing.
Why the Call Was Surprising
The cancellation is a surprise because *Sweet Magnolias* was neither failing nor expensive.
Deadline reports that Season 5, which debuted June 11, drew 2.8 million views in its opening week — down 30% from Season 4's premiere week, a relatively modest decline for a Netflix series this year — and rose to 3.5 million views in its first full week.
Since its 2020 debut, the South Carolina drama has earned 100 million views and appeared in the Global Weekly Top 10 fourteen times across more than 60 countries.
Deadline also notes the show is done on a modest budget, which explains its five-season, 50-episode run with solid viewership and a devoted fan following.
The deciding factor, per Deadline, was that Anderson and Swisher's new series was heating up internally and ready to go, so Netflix chose between the two rather than continuing both.
Inside the Last-Minute Decision
Deadline reports that Netflix ran out the clock on the decision: the options on the *Sweet Magnolias* cast were allowed to expire Thursday night, which was also when *Ladies of the House* was picked up, and the *Sweet Magnolias* cancellation followed on Friday, September 18.
The streamer also did not commission a Season 6 writers room ahead of time the way it typically does for established shows, another sign of the wait-and-see approach it took with the series.
Us Weekly corroborates the sequence, reporting that after options were up for the cast on Thursday, September 17, Netflix opted to cancel *Sweet Magnolias* and order *Ladies of the House*, leaving fans without the proper conclusion of a final season they had hoped for.
The New Series: Winery Drama, Sense and Sensibility DNA
*Ladies of the House* is loosely based on Lauren Edmondson's novel and, like *Sweet Magnolias*, centers on three women.
In the series, when the charismatic owner of a winery dies unexpectedly, his wife and two adult daughters must battle through their issues with each other in order to confront challenges with the business, their extended family, and the men in their lives.
Us Weekly describes it as a modern retelling of *Sense and Sensibility*.
Swisher said in a statement quoted by Variety that she fell in love with the characters Daisy, Cricket and Wallis — their relationships, their messiness, their strength, and most of all their heart — and called Netflix her creative home for the past seven years.
Anderson, quoted by Variety, said she immediately saw the foundation for a series centered on three women grappling with family, friendship and romance.
How the Story Ends for Fans
Fans hoping for a sixth season to resolve the show's cliffhangers are not left completely in the lurch.
Deadline reports that while there were several cliffhangers in the Season 5 finale, there were no major jaw-dropping twists, and the finale once again ended with the eponymous Magnolias — Swisher, Elliott and Headley — doing a margarita toast.
When Deadline asked Anderson in June whether the closer was crafted to also work as a series finale, she said the show always strives to balance the tension of open questions with emotional satisfaction, and that in some cases the emotional satisfaction and joy is greater than the open questions.
The show's writers posted a farewell on Instagram, quoted by Us Weekly: "All grand adventures must eventually end. And here, dear friends, is where ours goes."
What Comes Next
Anderson will again serve as showrunner on *Ladies of the House*, executive producing alongside Swisher and Kate Gordon under their Rolling Clover banner as well as Black Label Media, according to Deadline.
Swisher told Variety she is excited to continue telling meaningful, female-driven stories alongside Anderson, bringing the adaptation to life through Rolling Clover with partners at Black Label.
For Netflix, the swap preserves a proven creative pairing within its comfort-drama slate: Deadline notes *Sweet Magnolias* was part of the streamer's slate of comfort-food, feel-good series, and *Ladies of the House* carries the same three-women structure that defined the departing show.
All five seasons of *Sweet Magnolias* are currently streaming on Netflix.
Sources
- deadline.com › Netflix Cancels 'Sweet Magnolias', Orders 'Ladies Of The House' (Excl)
- variety.com › 'Sweet Magnolias' Canceled at Netflix as Sheryl J. Anderson and JoAnna Garcia Swisher Set New Series 'Ladies of the House'
- usmagazine.com › 'Sweet Magnolias' Ends After Season 5 in Shocking Cancellation, Netflix Orders New Show