Cleveland's ROSY Is Ohio's Only Entry on NYT 2026 List

The New York Times named Cleveland's open-fire restaurant ROSY to its 50 favorite U.S. restaurants of 2026, making it the Buckeye State's only entry.

@sharedot

Cleveland's ROSY Is Ohio's Only Entry on NYT 2026 List

By @sharedot · · 7 pages

  • Food
  • Restaurants
  • New York Times
  • Cleveland
  • Rosy

The New York Times named Cleveland's open-fire restaurant ROSY to its 50 favorite U.S. restaurants of 2026, making it the Buckeye State's only entry.

What Happened

The New York Times released its annual list of 50 favorite U.S. restaurants for 2026 this week, and ROSY, an open-fire restaurant in Cleveland's Ohio City neighborhood, made the cut. According to Signal Cleveland, ROSY is the only restaurant in Ohio on this year's list.

The restaurant opened in February 2026 and is led by chef Vinnie Cimino, an Akron native, and his business partner Andrew Watts, whose first venture together was Cordelia in downtown Cleveland, which opened in July 2022.

Why It's Surprising

A Cleveland restaurant landing on the New York Times' national list is rare enough that Cimino himself sounded stunned. "Things I never thought I would see in my lifetime is a Cleveland restaurant in The New York Times, let alone one of ours," he told Signal Cleveland.

The historical context underscores the surprise: Signal Cleveland reports this is only the third time an Ohio restaurant has made the list since the Times launched it in October 2021, following Columbus' now-shuttered Chapman's Eat Market in 2021 and Cincinnati's Wildweed in 2025.

The Evidence

Times reporter Brett Anderson's review, quoted by Signal Cleveland, praised ROSY's Istrian Peninsula-inspired cooking, from what he called "luscious ajvar red pepper sauce" to "juicy, housemade cotechino sausage."

The selection process was rigorous and unannounced: per the New York Post, 16 reporters and editors dined at 538 restaurants across 38 states, paying their own way with no free meals, with editor Brian Gallagher writing that the final picks came down to vibes — "You know it when you feel it."

Cimino adds résumé depth as a two-time James Beard Award finalist and a 2025 Food & Wine best new chef, per Signal Cleveland.

What Sets ROSY Apart

"One day it's 17 pounds of tomatoes and two bunches of Swiss chard," Cimino said. The restaurant also keeps things casual, with walk-ins making up the majority of diners.

Elsewhere on the list, the New York Post reports California landed six entries, including Komal in South LA and Glendale's Yerord Mas Bakery & Deli.

What Comes Next

ROSY is open Thursday through Sunday, and Cimino expects the restaurant to be busier than usual now that the list has been published — this week marks its first service since the announcement.

Per Signal Cleveland, he doesn't want the crowd to deter anyone: "Walk in. That's the whole point. Make us a part of your night." The nod also raises the profile for Cimino and Watts, who now have both a Times-listed restaurant and Cordelia under their belt.

Sources

  1. signalcleveland.org › Cleveland's ROSY makes New York Times restaurant list
  2. nypost.com › California hot spots make NYT's best restaurants of 2026 list
  3. nbcchicago.com › Suburban Chicago Greek restaurant makes NYT's restaurant list for 2026

More on Food