UMass Stuns Rutgers 37-21 as 29.5-Point Underdog

Coming off a 0-12 season, UMass routed Rutgers 37-21 in the season opener, snapping the nation's longest losing streak in shocking fashion.

@sharedot

UMass Stuns Rutgers 37-21 as 29.5-Point Underdog

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • Sports
  • College Football
  • Umass
  • Rutgers
  • Upset

Coming off a 0-12 season, UMass routed Rutgers 37-21 in the season opener, snapping the nation's longest losing streak in shocking fashion.

What happened in Piscataway

UMass, a 29.5-point underdog, blasted Rutgers 37-21 on Thursday night in the season opener in Piscataway, N.J., snapping a 16-game losing streak and scoring what The New York Times calls the biggest upset in school history.

After trailing 7-0 early, the Minutemen scored touchdowns on their first three possessions and forced five Rutgers turnovers. They outrushed the Scarlet Knights 200-30 and averaged 6.4 yards per play.

Quarterback William "Pop" Watson, a Virginia Tech transfer, completed 19 of 22 passes for 197 yards and three touchdowns and added 40 rushing yards, per The New York Times; USA Today and CBS Sports put his line at 189 yards on 18-of-21 passing with three touchdowns.

Why the upset defied all odds

CBS Sports reports that FBS teams favored by 29-plus points had gone 213-0 since 2024 entering the game, and Rutgers' 16-point loss was the fifth-largest by a favorite of 25-plus points since 2000. According to the New York Post, the Action Network called it the biggest outright upset in five years.

The result was no fluke: CBS Sports notes UMass scored on each of its first four drives and didn't punt until 100 seconds remained in the third quarter.

Dave Portnoy, who had bet Rutgers -29.5 as his "strongest play of the year," publicly apologized for the pick and later wrote that the effort was the most pathetic he had ever seen, per the New York Post.

The streak that finally ended

USA Today details the losing skid the win erased: UMass had not won since beating Wagner on Oct. 26, 2024 — 677 days earlier — and had not beaten an FBS opponent since topping Army on Oct. 28, 2023.

The 37 points were the most UMass has scored since 2024, and the 16-point margin was its most decisive against an FBS team since 2018, according to USA Today.

The New York Times reports it was just the program's second win against a current Power 4 team since joining the FBS in 2012, with the first against an independent BYU in 2018; its last win over a true major-conference team came in 1978 against Boston College.

How UMass dismantled Rutgers

The Minutemen won in every phase. CBS Sports reports UMass generated seven tackles for loss and five sacks against a Big Ten offensive line, won the turnover battle 4-0 with three interceptions of quarterback Dylan Lonergan, and held Rutgers to 1.2 yards per rushing attempt.

Perhaps the pivotal play came late in the third quarter, when the defense stuffed Rutgers on 4th-and-1 from the UMass 11-yard line. Elijah Faulkner also caught his second touchdown of the game to help UMass take the lead, per Fox News video.

K.J. Duff was Rutgers' lone bright spot with nine catches for 196 yards and three touchdowns, The New York Times reports.

What it means for both programs

The victory marks the first win at UMass for second-year coach Joe Harasymiak, who served three seasons as Rutgers' defensive coordinator under Greg Schiano before taking the job, The New York Times reports.

It erases a 2025 season in which UMass went 0-12, ranking last nationally in both points scored (11.1 per game) and allowed (38.6), per The New York Times and USA Today.

For Rutgers, the defeat raises hard questions about Schiano's direction: The New York Times notes the Scarlet Knights are 31-42 since his 2020 return, and a buyout after this season would cost $17.3 million.

Rutgers paid UMass $1.55 million for the guarantee game, according to On The Banks via The New York Times and FBSchedules via USA Today.

What comes next

With the streak gone, USA Today reports UMass can now target another program first: its first conference title game and a bowl appearance, as the Minutemen remain the only FBS program yet to play in a bowl game, excluding newcomers North Dakota State and Sacramento State.

Athletic director Ryan Bamford told USA Today Sports that significant investment in the program has yielded optimism, saying, "Nobody's running from the idea" of winning as many games as possible.

Rutgers, meanwhile, next plays Boston College on Sept. 11, per the New York Post, needing a response after a loss that quickly turned into a national punchline.

Sources

  1. nytimes.com › UMass goes from 0-12 to dominating Rutgers as 29.5-point underdog in opener
  2. usatoday.com › UMass snaps longest college football losing streak with rout of Rutgers
  3. cbssports.com › UMass shocks Rutgers: By the numbers as Minutemen snap nation's longest losing streak
  4. nypost.com › Dave Portnoy apologizes for his 'strongest play' Rutgers bet with ugly loss to UMass
  5. foxnews.com › Elijah Faulkner catches second TD of game, helping UMass take lead over Rutgers

More on Sports