Judge Halts Lindsay Clancy Mistrial, Gives Defense One Hour to Appeal
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- US News
- Lindsay Clancy
- Mistrial
A Massachusetts judge said he would declare a mistrial in Lindsay Clancy's triple murder trial after a third jury deadlock, but paused the ruling so the defense could file an emergency appeal.
What Happened in the Courtroom
Plymouth Superior Court Judge William Sullivan told the court Friday morning, "I'm going to declare a mistrial at this point," after the jury sent a note saying it remained deadlocked after seven days of deliberations.
The jury's note read, "It is with a heavy heart that we report we are unable to come to a unanimous decision and will not be able to."
Why the Defense Fought the Mistrial
Reddington argued the mistrial declaration was premature and asked Sullivan either to remove the holdout juror and replace him with an alternate or to order continued deliberations.
According to Rolling Stone, Reddington said the male holdout had "made statements acknowledging doubt" but "will not apply reasonable doubt to the evidence to return a not guilty verdict." The Independent described the request as a last-minute "Hail Mary."
Reddington also said he would be ready for a quick retrial, telling reporters, "Bring it. I've got witnesses lined up. We're all set."
The Deadlock Timeline
The first deadlock note came Tuesday, the fourth day of deliberations. On Wednesday the jury sent a second note saying it was "still unable to come to a unanimous decision," prompting Sullivan to read Tuey-Rodriguez instructions urging one last effort at a verdict.
Under Massachusetts law, a judge can ask a jury to keep deliberating only twice unless jurors consent, so a third deadlock allowed the mistrial.
The Case: Psychosis Versus Planning
Clancy pleaded not guilty to three counts of first-degree murder in the January 24, 2023, strangling deaths of her children Cora, 5, Dawson, 3, and Callan, 8 months, in their Duxbury home.
The defense argued she was not criminally responsible due to postpartum psychosis, a rare psychiatric emergency, citing testimony from forensic psychiatrist Dr. Phillip Resnick and claims of command hallucinations.
Prosecutors argued she was in control, saying she timed her husband's dinner and CVS errand, called the pharmacy to confirm a medication in stock, and methodically killed the children before attempting suicide.
Why the Trial Gripped the Nation
The livestreamed trial became a viral phenomenon and cast a spotlight on gaps in maternal mental healthcare. Jurors heard that Clancy, a former labor and delivery nurse, was prescribed more than a dozen psychiatric medications over roughly four months from a rotating cast of prescribers.
Online, mothers shared their own postpartum struggles, and supporters gathered outside the courtroom. Prosecutors countered that the case was not a debate about the mental health system, arguing Clancy had denied voices, suicide plans, and thoughts of harming others to her psychiatrist.
What Happens Next
The mistrial ruling was on hold as Reddington had one hour to file an emergency stay with the Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts. If the mistrial is ultimately declared, prosecutors must decide whether to retry the case, offer a plea deal, or drop the charges.
A conviction could mean life in prison, while a not-guilty-by-reason-of-insanity verdict would likely have led to indefinite commitment in a forensic psychiatric facility. Both Lindsay and Patrick Clancy have filed separate lawsuits against her medical providers.
Sources
- nbcnews.com › Lindsay Clancy judge says he'll declare a mistrial, but grants defense one hour to appeal
- rollingstone.com › Judge Declares Mistrial in Lindsay Clancy Trial, Grants One-Hour Delay for Defense to Appeal
- the-independent.com › Lindsay Clancy judge ready to declare mistrial but sets 1-hour deadline
- ibtimes.sg › Lindsay Clancy: Can Judge Declare Mistrial? Defense Attorney Wants 'Quick Retrial'
- upi.com › Lindsay Clancy jurors begin day 6, get 'dynamite charge'
- wflanews.iheart.com › Judge Declares Mistrial in Lindsay Clancy Triple Murder Case