NFL.com Ranks Styles No. 1, Reese No. 2 Among Rookies

nfl.com's defensive rookie rankings put Sonny Styles over Arvell Reese at the quarter mark, even as CBS Sports and Giants outlets lean Reese's way.

@sharedot

NFL.com Ranks Styles No. 1, Reese No. 2 Among Rookies

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • Style
  • NFL Rookies
  • Linebackers
  • Giants
  • Commanders

nfl.com's defensive rookie rankings put Sonny Styles over Arvell Reese at the quarter mark, even as CBS Sports and Giants outlets lean Reese's way.

Two Ohio State Linebackers Top the Rookie Board

nfl.com's quarter-mark ranking of the 2026 class's best defensive rookies puts Commanders linebacker Sonny Styles first and Giants linebacker Arvell Reese second, calling the pair the easiest selections on the list.

The outlet says it is far too early for definitive judgments but that this rookie crop is 'absolutely LOADED' at off-ball linebacker, so the 'backers dominate the top 10 — with Dillon Thieneman (No. 3), Mansoor Delane (No. 4) and Jacob Rodriguez (No. 5) behind them.

Both Buckeyes came off the board as top-10 picks in April and, per nfl.com, have 'hit the ground running (and hitting).'

Why Styles Takes the No. 1 Spot

nfl.com concedes Styles 'doesn't have the best stats among rookie defenders, but it sure feels like he's popped the most.'

The site points to his Week 1 arrival, bulldozing Saquon Barkley en route to a sack, and his NFC Defensive Player of the Week award in Washington's upset of the Super Bowl champion Seahawks — five tackles, two pass breakups, a forced fumble and an interception.

The 6-foot-5, 243-pound converted safety has even worn the green dot at times for Dan Quinn's injury-hit linebacker corps, and nfl.com writes that it is 'not sure what Styles can't do.'

The Case the Giants Sites Make for Reese

CBS Sports frames the question directly: did the Giants make the right choice at No. 5, when both players were available? Its answer: 'there might not have been a wrong answer.'

CBS notes Reese leads the entire NFL with 26 solo tackles, won Week 4 Rookie of the Week, and has grown more vital since Brian Burns' season-ending torn ACL. GMEN HQ goes further, arguing Reese has already made the Giants the draft's biggest winner and questioning why the Jets passed on him at No.

What the Numbers Say — and Where They Disagree

The stat lines vary by outlet: nfl.com credits Reese with an NFL-leading 26 solo tackles, while Big Blue View's table lists 34 total tackles (27 solo) and CBS counts 33.

On grading, both CBS and Big Blue View cite Pro Football Focus figures putting Reese at 77.1 and Styles at 76.9 — top-five rookie linebackers — with Reese second (+275) and Styles third (+750) in DraftKings' Defensive Rookie of the Year odds, per CBS.

CBS also reports Styles owns the highest pressure rate (17.9%) among rookie defenders with at least 25 pass-rush snaps, per Next Gen Stats.

A Matchup Written in the Schedule

Both wear No. 52, and Big Blue View notes they became the first college linebacker teammates selected in the top 10 of the same draft.

Analysts quoted by Big Blue View mostly lean Reese: Draft on SI's Justin Melo calls Reese the better long-term asset, while The Athletic's Nick Baumgardner argues Styles has the elite coverage ceiling. A quote from SB Nation's Hogs Haven even likens Styles' demeanor to Bobby Wagner's.

What Comes Next for Both Rookies

CBS's verdict is that the first-month comparison is 'a wash' and the full accounting will not be complete for years.

The Giants' choice looks vindicated given Burns' injury and Reese's edge-rushing snap share climbing above 46% in Week 4, per an ESPN excerpt quoted by Big Blue View; GMEN HQ adds that PFF named Reese to its second-team All-Pro defense through the first quarter.

For Styles, nfl.com says his versatility suits Washington, where he organizes the defense as a 21-year-old. If the first quarter of the season is any guide, both teams got their Buckeye.

Sources

  1. nfl.com › NFL defensive rookie rankings at quarter mark of 2026 season: Sonny Styles or Arvell Reese at No. 1?
  2. cbssports.com › Arvell Reese, Sonny Styles to meet in Week 5: Did Giants make right choice between first-round linebackers?
  3. bigblueview.com › Arvell Reese vs. Sonny Styles: Which rookie linebacker has been, will be, better?
  4. gmenhq.com › Arvell Reese already has Giants emerging as the 2026 NFL Draft's biggest winner

More on Style