Texas BBQ Joint Pulls Brisket From Menu as Beef Costs Soar

Butter's BBQ in Sinton, Texas, says brisket ate over 70% of its grocery costs, so owner Andrew Soto pulled it from the everyday menu.

@sharedot

Texas BBQ Joint Pulls Brisket From Menu as Beef Costs Soar

By @sharedot · · 7 pages

  • Food
  • Bbq
  • Beef Prices
  • Restaurants

Butter's BBQ in Sinton, Texas, says brisket ate over 70% of its grocery costs, so owner Andrew Soto pulled it from the everyday menu.

The Decision That Shocked Texas BBQ Fans

Butter's BBQ in Sinton, a small town about a 30-minute drive from Corpus Christi, has removed brisket from its standard menu — a move that borders on heresy in the Lone Star State.

Fox News Digital reports that owner Andrew Soto described the choice as anything but sudden, noting his restaurant had absorbed beef and brisket price hikes for roughly five years before the costs became unmanageable.

In a Facebook post to its community, the restaurant apologized, writing that it could no longer sustain its business model with brisket eating up over 70% of its total grocery costs.

Soto stressed the decision was not personal: 'We're just trying to protect our business and our livelihood,' he said, while urging customers to keep coming for the barbecue that remains.

Why brisket became an unsustainable gamble

According to Fox News, the breaking point came when a food rep told Soto that brisket had gone up in price again — by almost $1 per pound.

That may sound small, Soto acknowledged, but it multiplies fast when a smokehouse buys hundreds of pounds of beef at once, and in a small town it is hard to predict how much will actually sell.

When Butter's BBQ tried raising prices and cooking less brisket, foot traffic and sales took a hit, so paying steep prices for a cut that might not move became too much of a 'gamble.'

The USDA's Economic Research Service, cited by Fox News, puts beef and veal prices 5.9% higher in August 2026 than a year earlier, with a 9.4% increase forecast for all of 2026.

Pork takes over the pit — brisket goes pre-order only

Brisket is not vanishing entirely, but it is leaving the everyday lineup. Fox News reports that Butter's BBQ is prioritizing pork, steering guests toward ribs and sausage while experimenting with beef cheek as a brisket alternative.

True brisket devotees will still be able to get their fix through a new online pre-order system where customers order and pay in advance — an approach that eliminates the waste risk that made daily brisket unsustainable. 'We're in Texas.

It's a big deal,' Soto said of the cut's cultural weight. Yahoo carried the owner's video explaining the difficult choice, amplifying the story beyond the local community.

Customers split: raise prices or bring on the pork

The menu change ignited debate on the restaurant's Facebook announcement.

Fox News notes some commenters insisted brisket is essential at any Texas barbecue joint, with one warning 'not selling brisket will hurt your business' and another arguing the better move is raising prices — pointing to brisket sandwiches that have climbed from $10–$12 to $20 elsewhere.

Others were more supportive, with one cheering 'Bring on the pork!!!' and another suggesting smoked pork steaks as an affordable menu addition.

The split captures a wider tension in barbecue country: whether loyal customers will accept higher prices or welcome cheaper cuts as beef costs keep climbing.

What the brisket pull signals for 2026 dining

With the USDA expecting beef prices to rise as much as 11.6% in 2026 at the top of its forecast interval — per the Fox News report — Butter's BBQ may be a preview of more menu shakeups to come, especially at small-town smokehouses without big-city volume.

The National Cattlemen's Beef Association was contacted by Fox News Digital for comment, and Soto's move shows operators testing structural fixes rather than simply passing costs along: pre-order systems, alternative cuts like beef cheek, and a deliberate pivot to pork.

For now, Soto's message to his community stands: 'We still have some really good barbecue, despite not having the brisket on our menu.'

Sources

  1. foxnews.com › Texas BBQ joint takes drastic step as soaring beef prices devour restaurant
  2. yahoo.com › Texas barbecue restaurant owner forced to cut brisket from menu due to rising beef prices

More on Food