CFTC Files Crypto Rulemakings After Clarity Act Fails
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- Crypto
- Cftc
- Clarity Act
- Regulation
Two days after the Senate rejected the CLARITY Act 49-50, the CFTC sent a crypto rulemaking package to the White House, joining an SEC push on tokenized stocks.
What Happened
Startup Fortune reports that on September 15, 2026, the Senate rejected cloture on H.R.
Two days later, on September 17, the CFTC sent a crypto rulemaking package titled "Regulation Crypto Asset Transactions" and "Regulation Crypto Asset Markets" to the White House's Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs.
Why It's Surprising
The industry spent years asking Congress for a statute, and instead of regrouping for another legislative attempt, the regulatory initiative has visibly jumped to the agencies.
Digital Today reports that industry attention has since moved to the SEC and CFTC, with Kristin Smith of the Solana Policy Institute calling agency guidance the more realistic path for now.
The reversal is notable because the bill was the industry's main shot at putting the CFTC in a larger role and pulling the SEC back from parts of the market — and regulators are now filling that space themselves.
The Evidence
Startup Fortune reports that OIRA's public docket shows the CFTC submission arrived September 17 under RIN 3038-AF80 at the prerule stage — no rule text, no comment deadline, no effective date yet.
The filing followed August remarks in which CFTC Chairman Michael S. Selig directed staff to explore rules letting registrants and crypto exchanges seek designation as a designated contract market for margined crypto trading.
Separately, Digital Today reports the SEC unveiled steps on September 17 opening a path for on-chain trading of tokenized U.S. stocks, and that CFTC staff also set a zero-tolerance stance toward passive software providers.
The Stakes
Startup Fortune reports that the SEC had already proposed its own Regulation Crypto Assets, published in the Federal Register on August 21 with comments due October 20, meaning the industry now faces three moving parts: a failed Senate vote, an SEC proposal, and a CFTC package at OIRA.
The CFTC's authority is also narrower than the bill's — it can oversee derivatives and registered contract markets and police fraud in commodity spot markets, but under current law it cannot simply declare full federal authority over ordinary spot trading in bitcoin, ether or other tokens on every exchange.
The Political Fight
The blame game spread quickly after the vote. Digital Today reports that Republicans argued Democrats never intended to move the bill, while Democrats said the vote was forced before negotiations ended; Senator Cynthia Lummis said Democrats were not serious about consumer protection.
Senator Angela Alsobrooks told Crypto in America that "the Clarity Act will not disappear," and six Democratic negotiators said bipartisan talks would continue.
Startup Fortune reports AP attributed Democratic pushback partly to President Trump's crypto interests, including World Liberty Financial revenue.
What Comes Next
Startup Fortune reports that the rulemaking must grind through notice and comment, White House review and a full commission process, and that The Block's reporting on the OIRA filing points to a late 2027 timeline at the earliest.
In the meantime, the current mix of state licenses, agency interpretations, no-action letters and court fights stays in place, with the SEC's tokenized-stocks relief and any CFTC lane for registered venues offering the nearest clarity.
Michael Saylor has argued the industry should use the next two years to scale products under existing regulators and convert temporary relief into durable rules.