Prediction Markets Narrowly Favor Fed Rate Hike at Sept 16 FOMC

Prediction markets put a 25-basis-point Fed hike slightly ahead of a hold at the September 16 meeting, with no participants pricing a cut.

@sharedot

Prediction Markets Narrowly Favor Fed Rate Hike at Sept 16 FOMC

By @sharedot · · 7 pages

  • Finance
  • Federal Reserve
  • Inflation
  • Interest Rates

Prediction markets put a 25-basis-point Fed hike slightly ahead of a hold at the September 16 meeting, with no participants pricing a cut.

What happened

Prediction markets on the September 15-16 Federal Open Market Committee decision show enormous volume of more than $42 million, with slightly more than half of participants expecting the Fed to raise rates by 25 basis points and just over 45% expecting the rate to be maintained, according to Federal News Network.

Despite President Trump's pressure campaign for lower rates, the outlet reports that essentially no one in the market expects a cut.

That split reflects a genuinely contested decision: a strong August jobs report and pending inflation data have pushed a hike to the top of the plausible outcomes, while political pressure keeps a hold in play.

Why a hike is back on the table

The Real Economy Blog reports that economists expect a 0.4% monthly increase in both top-line PPI and CPI, with core PPI up 0.3% and core CPI up 0.2%. On a year-ago basis, top-line PPI is forecast to advance 5.2% and CPI 3.4%, with core CPI at 2.5%.

RSM chief economist Joe Brusuelas writes that the risk is CPI arriving at a 0.5% monthly pace, and that all signs point toward a rate hike at the September 16 policy meeting. His view is that only a top-line monthly increase of 0.25% or less would keep the Fed on hold.

Why this inflation is different

According to The Real Economy Blog, factors once thought temporary now look persistent: the war-induced energy shock is in its seventh month with crude above $90 per barrel and oil up more than 23% year over year, tariff pass-through is proving more enduring as the administration uses tariffs ad hoc, and the build-out of AI data centers is drawing on commodities and final goods in a way that drives prices higher.

The blog argues the Fed has effectively talked itself into a corner and needs to be bailed out by this week's data, since balance-sheet contraction is off the table and communications policy is confused, leaving only the federal funds rate as a working tool.

The skeptical counterpoint

Not everyone thinks the traditional playbook works. TradingView, citing a TS Lombard note by economist Steven Blitz, reports that private-sector borrowing accounts for a shrinking share of U.S. debt growth, potentially weakening the impact of higher interest rates.

Since 2012, federal debt growth has shown a stronger correlation with inflation, with a six-quarter lag, than private debt.

Blitz said Fed Chair Kevin Warsh may instead allow the yield curve to steepen — holding the funds rate while letting 10-year yields rise — and expects Warsh to find a way through the CPI data and avert a September hike.

Stakes and what comes next

Federal News Network reports that Trump has threatened to stop trading with countries where the U.S. runs a trade deficit if the Fed hikes, and frames the most likely outcome as a close call to maintain rates and push a hike down the road.

If the Fed does hike, the TS Lombard note warns the usual trade of buying 30-year Treasurys and selling 10-year notes might not work this time.

Sources

  1. federalnewsnetwork.com › Rate Hike Coming in September? Prediction Markets for Next Fed Decision
  2. realeconomy.rsmus.com › Market Minute: Inflation data set to support Fed rate hike
  3. tradingview.com › Warsh's rate hike puzzle: Why the old Fed playbook may fail

More on Finance