Albertsons Demands $9.3 Billion From Kroger in Court

Albertsons is demanding more than $9.3 billion from Kroger over their failed grocery merger, with a two-week Delaware trial set for later this month.

@sharedot

Albertsons Demands $9.3 Billion From Kroger in Court

By @sharedot · · 6 pages

  • Food
  • Grocery Merger
  • Kroger
  • Albertsons
  • Antitrust Litigation

Albertsons is demanding more than $9.3 billion from Kroger over their failed grocery merger, with a two-week Delaware trial set for later this month.

What Happened: A $9.3 Billion Bill for a Dead Deal

Albertsons' lawyers made the demand Monday in Delaware Chancery Court, where a two-week trial is slated later this month over blame for the collapse of the $24.6 billion merger between the two largest U.S. grocery chains, according to Bloomberg Law.

The company wants Judge Lori Will to find that Kroger 'willfully' breached the merger agreement by failing to use 'best efforts' to win regulatory approval, including a refusal to alter its plan to divest certain assets.

Albertsons puts the bill at more than $9.3 billion: a premium stockholders would have received had the deal closed, a $600 million termination fee, plus $75 million in interest and additional costs. 'The bottom line is that Kroger made a promise and broke it,' Albertsons said in a statement.

Why It's Surprising: The Acquirer Told It Reneged

The unusual twist is that Albertsons is suing its own merger partner rather than simply walking away after a federal court blocked the deal in December 2024, when the judge sided with the FTC's argument that the divestiture plan was insufficient to address antitrust concerns.

According to Bloomberg Law, Albertsons argues Kroger agreed 'to remove any antitrust impediment to the merger — with no limit except that Kroger did not have to divest more than 650 stores,' and that 'Kroger wanted the merger but only on its own terms.'

The companies had planned to sell hundreds of stores to C&S Wholesale Grocers to satisfy regulators, but Albertsons says Kroger 'stuck to its failing lowball strategy right through the litigation that ended the deal.'

Kroger's Defense: 'We Kept Our End of the Bargain'

Kroger says it owes Albertsons nothing.

In a separate court filing Monday, Bloomberg Law reports, Kroger said it 'kept its end of the bargain,' spending more than a billion dollars and 'countless hours of personnel time' pursuing the deal, and claims Albertsons failed to comply with its own obligations under the merger agreement — so is not entitled to a termination fee.

Kroger calls the demand for billions in additional damages a 'far-fetched' legal theory involving estimated taxes on the deal premium, and says it relied on the advice of its antitrust counsel in constructing the divestiture packages.

Kroger also accuses Albertsons of secretly working with C&S to push regulators to require more store divestitures than needed; C&S says its communications met contractual, legal and ethical obligations.

The Stakes: Grocery Competition and Merger Risk-Sharing

The merger would have seen Kroger, the largest U.S. grocery chain, acquire the No. 2 grocer to better compete against Amazon, Walmart and other non-unionized rivals, as The Seattle Times notes in its Bloomberg-syndicated coverage.

If Albertsons wins, its stockholders benefit — private equity firm Cerberus Capital Management holds a more than 30% stake as of the end of June.

Kroger's attorneys warn that crediting Albertsons' 'endless second-guessing' would turn contractual control over regulatory strategy, traditionally accorded to the acquirer, into a guaranteed payout for targets when regulatory efforts fail, making it 'almost impossible to negotiate risk-sharing in merger agreements.'

The case is Albertsons v. Kroger, 2024-1276, in Delaware's Court of Chancery.

Sources

  1. news.bloomberglaw.com › Albertsons Seeks More Than $9 Billion for Busted Kroger Deal
  2. seattletimes.com › Albertsons seeks more than $9B over busted Kroger deal

More on Food