Judge Rules Trump Order to Halve FEMA Staffing Illegal

A federal judge ruled Friday that DHS unlawfully ordered FEMA to cut its workforce in half and rebuked officials for deleting Signal messages tied to the plan.

@sharedot

Judge Rules Trump Order to Halve FEMA Staffing Illegal

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • US News
  • Fema
  • Federal Courts
  • Homeland Security
  • Labor Unions

A federal judge ruled Friday that DHS unlawfully ordered FEMA to cut its workforce in half and rebuked officials for deleting Signal messages tied to the plan.

What happened

US District Judge Susan Illston in Northern California ruled Friday that the Trump administration's order for FEMA to cut its staffing nearly in half was illegal, finding that the Department of Homeland Security "acted arbitrarily and capriciously" when it revoked FEMA's authority to renew contracts for its on-call disaster response teams.

According to Newsweek's account of the 32-page order, DHS directed a plan to reduce the agency from about 23,000 employees to roughly 11,500 and blocked renewal of hundreds of temporary disaster-response workers.

The judge wrote that DHS "acted unlawfully in usurping FEMA's authority over its personnel."

Why the ruling stings

The decision is a rebuke to a centerpiece of the administration's downsizing push, and the judge's language was unusually sharp.

According to the AP report carried by the Bozeman Daily Chronicle, Illston wrote that the FEMA staffing plan number "appears as if pulled from thin air," noting top DHS officials directed the cut even though the agency's own supervisors objected.

Congress passed a 2006 law after Hurricane Katrina stating the homeland security secretary "may not substantially or significantly reduce" FEMA's authorities, responsibilities, or functions, and Illston found the staffing move violated those post-Katrina protections designed to preserve FEMA's independence within DHS.

The deleted Signal evidence

In a separate filing, Illston said the use of the messaging app Signal by former acting FEMA head Karen Evans and former DHS deputy chief of staff Joseph Guy violated federal law and department policy.

According to CNN, Evans created a chat relevant to the case with messages set to auto-delete after four weeks, then shortened the timer in March after being named a defendant.

The court found her actions intentional, writing that "Evans should have known better" because she previously served as DHS Chief Information Officer in charge of records preservation. Illston said the court will presume the lost messages would have been unfavorable to defendants.

The stakes for disaster response

The CORE teams at the center of the case make up about 40% of FEMA's workforce and are often the first federal boots on the ground when hurricanes and other large disasters strike, overseeing aid distribution and long-term funding to states and communities.

Traditionally they served two-to-four-year contracts that were almost always renewed, but DHS limited renewals to 180 days at a time in 2025 and in January instructed FEMA to let some contracts lapse.

What the unions won — and didn't

The ruling is a win for the American Federation of Government Employees and the AFL-CIO, the labor unions behind the broader lawsuit against the administration's federal workforce cuts. But Illston did not immediately order specific remedies.

According to Straight Arrow, if the parties cannot agree on the scope of relief, they must file a joint statement on what remains outstanding by October 9, after which the court will rule on what relief is given.

The judge rejected the unions' bid to rescind all non-renewal notices as too broad, since FEMA is no longer systemically declining renewals, though she said DHS "continues to usurp FEMA's authority" by capping contracts at 180 days.

What comes next

The parties must now meet and agree on the scope of relief, with a joint filing due October 9 if negotiations fail, and Illston will issue a separate ruling on any remedy.

FEMA responded that it "continues to maintain a roster of experienced leadership and support staff across headquarters and regional offices," while DHS did not immediately respond to requests for comment, according to the AP.

The ruling also arrives against a backdrop of heavy attrition: the GAO reported in August that more than 4,300 employees, about 17% of FEMA's workforce, separated in the 2025 budget year, a loss it said eroded institutional knowledge and exacerbated longstanding workforce challenges.

Sources

  1. cnn.com › Judge rules Trump administration order to fire FEMA staffers was illegal
  2. newsweek.com › Federal judge says Trump plan to halve FEMA workforce was unlawful
  3. bozemandailychronicle.com › Federal judge rules Trump DHS plan for 50% FEMA staffing cuts was unlawful
  4. san.com › Judge rules DHS acted illegally by telling FEMA to cut half its staff

More on US News