25 States Sue to Restore Power Plant Carbon Limits

A coalition of 25 states, cities and counties has asked a federal appeals court to overturn the EPA's repeal of the 2024 Carbon Pollution Standards.

@sharedot

25 States Sue to Restore Power Plant Carbon Limits

By @sharedot · · 7 pages

  • Climate
  • Epa
  • Carbon Pollution Standards
  • Power Plants
  • Litigation

A coalition of 25 states, cities and counties has asked a federal appeals court to overturn the EPA's repeal of the 2024 Carbon Pollution Standards.

What happened: a petition in the D.C. Circuit

On October 1, a coalition of 25 states, cities and counties filed a petition for review in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, asking the court to overturn the EPA's repeal of the 2024 Carbon Pollution Standards for coal- and gas-fired power plants.

Quantum Commodity Intelligence reports the same coalition launch against the repeal. According to Daily Dodge, the group includes attorneys general from 20 states plus the District of Columbia, Pennsylvania's governor, the mayors of New York City and Chicago, and the City and County of Denver.

Why this fight matters

The repeal strips greenhouse gas limits from the plants that Daily Dodge says produce about one-quarter of U.S. carbon dioxide emissions.

The coalition also notified the EPA of its intent to sue over the agency's failure to regulate greenhouse gas pollution from existing natural gas plants, including 'peaker' units that run during high demand — many of which, the department says, sit in low-income communities and communities of color.

Standards for new gas plants were issued more than a decade ago, but existing plants have never been covered.

The legal argument

In its petition, the coalition argues the EPA unlawfully repealed the pollution standards without adequately considering alternatives or the health and economic costs of allowing additional emissions, and failed to properly calculate the costs of repealing the rule.

Daily Dodge quotes Wisconsin Attorney General Josh Kaul: 'The EPA should be protecting us from pollution, not clearing the way for it.' The coalition frames the rollback as a choice of more wildfire smoke, more extreme weather and more harms to health.

Wisconsin's climate bill

The Wisconsin DOJ's own filings put local stakes in concrete terms.

Daily Dodge reports the department cited a 2020 University of Wisconsin study finding that extreme heat kills more Wisconsin residents than all other weather disasters combined, and a 2024 Center for Climate Integrity estimate that Wisconsin communities could face more than $16 billion in costs to protect themselves from climate change impacts.

The department warns the state faces increased heat, extreme storms and severe precipitation as emissions rise.

What comes next, on both sides of the Atlantic

The case now heads into the D.C. Circuit, where courts will test whether the repeal can stand, while the separate intent-to-sue over existing gas plants adds a second legal front.

Meanwhile, the scientific baseline keeps advancing: CORDIS reports that the EU-funded PALOMA project has assembled the most comprehensive modern pollen database for the Amazon basin, characterizing temperature and rainfall tolerances of plant taxa so researchers can model how lowland rainforest species respond to a warming climate.

Sources

  1. dailydodge.com › Wisconsin DOJ challenges EPA rollback of power plant pollution limits
  2. qcintel.com › US states file lawsuit challenging repeal of power plant GHG limits
  3. cordis.europa.eu › Investigating how Amazonian plants respond to climate change

More on Climate