Judge Rejects Gemini and CFTC's Bid to Undo $5M Settlement

A Manhattan federal judge rejected Gemini and the CFTC's joint bid to vacate the exchange's $5 million settlement, leaving it intact.

@sharedot

Judge Rejects Gemini and CFTC's Bid to Undo $5M Settlement

By @sharedot · · 7 pages

  • Crypto
  • Gemini
  • Cftc
  • Regulation

A Manhattan federal judge rejected Gemini and the CFTC's joint bid to vacate the exchange's $5 million settlement, leaving it intact.

What happened in Manhattan

US District Judge Alvin Hellerstein ruled Thursday that Gemini Trust Co and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission failed to meet the legal standards required to set aside a $5 million consent settlement entered in January 2025.

The unusual twist is that both sides asked for the same relief: Gemini, which fought the case for more than three years before settling shortly before trial, joined the very regulator that sued it in 2022 in a May 2026 motion to wipe out the judgment and court order entirely.

Why this filing was a reversal

This was not the familiar pattern of an exchange disputing a regulator's allegations.

This time the parties were aligned: the CFTC argued its own 2022 complaint would not have been filed under the Trump administration's narrower crypto enforcement priorities, and the pair told the court the agency had 'resorted to inappropriate tactics' in bringing the lawsuit.

Gemini even agreed it would not seek a refund of the $5 million penalty if the settlement were vacated. Despite having the agency that brought the original case on its side, the exchange could not undo a final court order.

The case behind the settlement

The CFTC sued Gemini in June 2022, alleging the exchange founded by Cameron and Tyler Winklevoss made false or misleading statements during the agency's review of a proposed Bitcoin futures contract.

According to Reuters via Devdiscourse, the January 2025 settlement came at the end of the Biden administration and shortly before trial.

Hellerstein, a Clinton appointee, found that Gemini had litigated against the CFTC for more than three years before voluntarily agreeing to settle, and that the agency's current view of the case did not require vacating the settlement.

The stakes for the industry

The ruling lands at a moment when Washington's approach to cryptocurrency has grown more favorable, and some crypto businesses may have hoped that changed politics could erase historical enforcement outcomes.

Hellerstein's decision signals otherwise: courts retain control of their judgments even when a regulatory agency changes its view of a case.

For the niche regulatory audience, the message is that a friendlier enforcement climate does not automatically reopen consent judgments, and companies cannot assume approved settlements disappear alongside the political circumstances in which they were reached.

What comes next

In the immediate term, little changes for Gemini: the settlement and permanent injunction remain in effect, no new fine was imposed, and the penalty will not be refunded under the terms the parties themselves proposed.

The CFTC and Gemini did not immediately respond to requests for comment after the ruling, according to Devdiscourse's Reuters syndication. The decision stands as a precedent-setting data point for other crypto firms watching whether the current enforcement posture can be used to unwind past deals.

Sources

  1. tradingview.com › Judge Rejects Gemini And CFTC Bid To Overturn $5 Million Settlement
  2. devdiscourse.com › Judge rejects CFTC, Gemini bid to vacate $5 million settlement
  3. coinedition.com › Judge Rejects CFTC, Gemini Bid to Overturn $5 Million Crypto Settlement

More on Crypto