First Reactions Split Iñárritu's 'Digger' as Box Office Looms

First reactions to Tom Cruise's 'Digger' split between 'baffling' and 'best since Magnolia,' while ScreenRant reports tracking projects a risky $20-30 million opening.

@sharedot

First Reactions Split Iñárritu's 'Digger' as Box Office Looms

By @sharedot · · 7 pages

  • Film
  • Tom Cruise
  • Digger
  • Box Office

First reactions to Tom Cruise's 'Digger' split between 'baffling' and 'best since Magnolia,' while ScreenRant reports tracking projects a risky $20-30 million opening.

What Happened: 'Digger' Faces the Press

Variety reports critics called it everything from "baffling" to "unpleasant" to "fascinating stuff," with most agreeing it is "like nothing you're expecting."

IndieWire's Jim Hemphill praised it as "Tom Cruise's best performance since 'Magnolia'" and "one of the most visually inventive, conceptually audacious, and unpredictable studio movies ever made," while Awards Radar's Joey Magidson called it a "mess" and critic Edward Douglas told Variety he expects a "HORRENDOUS CinemaScore."

The film stars Cruise as oil tycoon Digger Rockwell, with Riz Ahmed, John Goodman, Sandra Hüller, Michael Stuhlbarg and Jesse Plemons in support, and it world-premiered in London on Tuesday night with Prince William and Princess Catherine in attendance, according to Yahoo News UK.

Why It's Surprising: A Cruise Gamble in Doubt

The reaction split lands at a precarious moment. According to ScreenRant, "Digger" carries a reported $125 million budget but is tracking to open at just $20-$30 million domestically — and could lose its October 2 opening weekend to the Colleen Hoover adaptation "Verity."

ScreenRant notes that would give the 64-year-old star consecutive non-first-place finishes after "Mission: Impossible — The Final Reckoning" opened second behind "Lilo & Stitch" in 2025.

The film marks Cruise's first non-action role in nearly a decade, the outlet notes, since 2017's "American Made," making it a bet that his starpower transcends the stunt-driven genre that built his modern box office dominance.

The Evidence: Praise and Brickbats From Critics

The reactions span the full spectrum. IndieWire's Anne Thompson called it "a brave and gorgeous art film that will not score with mainstream audiences but will play best for the Academy, especially crafts and actors."

Variety's awards pundit Clayton Davis wrote that Tom Cruise and John Goodman are "delivering stellar work" but "not all the dots connect." The Oscar Expert called it "a satire about the role of satire — fascinating stuff," while journalist Mike Ryan found it "kind of generally unpleasant."

Variety also details Cruise's transformation into the title role via makeup and prosthetics that originally took six hours to apply, which he says on the "New Heights" podcast he drilled down to under an hour.

The Stakes: An Awards Play Meets a Cold Market

Much rides on the divide closing or hardening.

As ScreenRant frames it, "Digger" was positioned as a bold awards play for Cruise, who is seeking his first Oscar win and first acting nomination in decades — and the marketing campaign has been rocky, with early glimpses reportedly hiding the film's comedic tone.

What the film needs most, ScreenRant argues, is "some rave early reactions and strong Rotten Tomatoes scores," and the split first reactions may complicate that sell.

What Comes Next: Premiere, Release, and Rebound Plans

According to Yahoo News UK, the London world premiere doubled as this year's Royal Film Performance benefiting The Film and TV Charity, where Cruise thanked Prince William and Princess Catherine for "what they do for the arts" and praised Iñárritu as "one of one."

Cruise has also been on a promotional run spanning GQ, "The Tonight Show" and the "New Heights" podcast, per the same report.

And if "Digger" underperforms, ScreenRant reports his next projects — "Days of Thunder 2" with Anne Hathaway for summer 2028, followed by a planned "Top Gun 3" reunion with Joseph Kosinski — should return him to his blockbuster winning ways.

Sources

  1. variety.com › 'Digger' First Reactions Split Over Tom Cruise's 'Baffling,' 'Unpleasant' and 'Brave' New Movie
  2. screenrant.com › Tom Cruise's New Non-Action Movie Risks Continuing An Unusual Losing Streak
  3. uk.news.yahoo.com › Tom Cruise Welcomes Prince William and Kate Middleton at 'Digger' World Premiere in London

More on Film