Creatine Gains Strength and Muscle Even Without Exercise

A new 12-week randomized trial reports creatine monohydrate increased lean mass, strength and endurance in adults 45–65 who did no structured training.

@sharedot

Creatine Gains Strength and Muscle Even Without Exercise

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • Health
  • Fitness
  • Nutrition
  • Supplements

A new 12-week randomized trial reports creatine monohydrate increased lean mass, strength and endurance in adults 45–65 who did no structured training.

What happened

A 12-week randomized clinical study from Texas A&M University, published in the Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition, assigned 64 adults aged 45–65 to take either 10 grams of daily creatine monohydrate (5 grams morning and night) or a placebo.

Participants could choose whether to join a supervised resistance and aerobic training program three times a week, paired with a diet plan cutting 300 to 500 calories a day.

According to Women's Health, researchers assessed body measurements, blood tests and cognitive performance at the start, six weeks and twelve weeks, and concluded that creatine supplementation with and without exercise and diet may help middle-aged and older adults maintain muscle mass and strength.

Why it is surprising

Healthcare providers have generally believed creatine mainly helps when combined with exercise, so the finding that non-exercising participants gained lean tissue, strength and muscular endurance from the supplement alone breaks with that assumption.

'To my knowledge this is potentially new information as we previously believed creatine to primarily only help when combined with exercise,' Shane Davis, MD, a sports medicine physician and physiatrist at Tufts Medical Center, told Women's Health.

Lifespan Research Institute notes the trial also found creatine roughly doubled the effectiveness of exercise on muscle strength, with leg-press maximum rising about 34% with exercise plus creatine versus 18% with exercise plus placebo.

The evidence and its limits

According to Lifespan Research Institute, both creatine groups gained lean tissue while placebo groups showed little change, and creatine without exercise also improved bench-press strength relative to the non-exercising placebo group.

However, measured lean tissue is not necessarily all muscle — creatine increases body water, which affects DXA lean-mass estimates. Most overall cognitive analyses did not reach statistical significance, though a word recognition test favored creatine.

Women's Health reports researchers stressed the findings are still 'exploratory,' and Lifespan notes study co-author Richard Kreider, PhD, has previously conducted sponsored creatine research and sits on the board of the company that supplied the creatine.

Why creatine may work alone

Experts offered theories for the no-exercise effect.

Albert Matheny, RD, CSCS, co-founder of SoHo Strength Lab, told Women's Health that creatine is 'hyper hydrating' and easily taken up by muscles, expanding creatine phosphate stores — a natural energy system — and drawing more water into muscles, which supports protein use and creation.

Kreider pointed to brain energy: 'If you increase energy in the brain, you can think better,' he told Women's Health. He also suggested non-exercising participants simply had more energy for daily life, plus better cell hydration, which contributed to muscle gain.

The stakes

As people age, fat gain and muscle loss often occur together — a combination called sarcopenic obesity that undermines mobility and metabolic health, according to Lifespan Research Institute.

Weight loss itself risks stripping away more muscle, which is why a supplement that might preserve or build lean tissue on its own is significant for middle-aged and older adults.

Kreider told Women's Health the findings suggest 'creatine is important throughout the lifespan,' and that while many people take two to three grams, up to 10 grams daily may be needed for the cognitive benefits researchers are exploring.

What comes next

The study does not suggest creatine should replace exercise.

'Those who did combine [creatine] with exercise did see more substantial improvements than those who did not, and given the many benefits of exercise, I would still strongly recommend individuals use creatine as an adjunct to regular exercise, not as a replacement,' Dr. Davis told Women's Health.

Women's Health also notes anyone interested in taking creatine should check in with a healthcare provider first, since dosing can be tricky and side effects include GI discomfort and bloating. Researchers said far more work is needed to confirm these exploratory results.

Sources

  1. ca.style.yahoo.com › This Buzzy Supplement Could Increase Your Strength Without Exercise
  2. womenshealthmag.com › This Buzzy Supplement Could Increase Your Strength Without Exercise
  3. lifespan.io › Creatine Protects Lean Mass Even Without Exercise

More on Health