Lead in 99% of Cat Foods Tested, Study Finds

A Clean Label Project study of 100 cat foods found lead in 99%, with fish-based wet foods carrying far more mercury, per cited outlets.

@sharedot

Lead in 99% of Cat Foods Tested, Study Finds

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • Food
  • Pet Food Safety
  • Cat Food Contaminants

A Clean Label Project study of 100 cat foods found lead in 99%, with fish-based wet foods carrying far more mercury, per cited outlets.

What the study found

The Clean Label Project, a Colorado nonprofit, tested 100 top-selling cat food products from 62 brands for more than 122 environmental and industrial contaminants, according to reporting carried by USA Today and CNN via Scripps News.

Lead was detected in 99% of products, cadmium in 96%, and arsenic in 94%. Glyphosate appeared in 37% of samples, and the plastic chemical DEHP was found in 48 of the 100 products.

Toxins turned up across wet, dry and air- or freeze-dried formats, even in items marketed as natural or premium, the organization said.

Why the fish finding stands out

Fish- or seafood-based foods had about 18 times more mercury than other cat foods, and among wet foods, fish-based products had roughly 28 times more mercury than wet foods made with other meats, especially poultry, per USA Today. Fish foods also carried about 2.5 times more cadmium.

USA Today reports that 48.6% of fish and seafood products ranked among the highest mercury levels, while no poultry-based product did.

The evidence, and its limits

CNN's Sandee LaMotte, as carried by Scripps News, reports the study compared contaminant levels across categories but was not designed to determine whether a particular product could cause illness or harm.

Each product came from a single batch, most brands contributed only one product, and results could not capture batch-to-batch variation — caveats the researchers themselves emphasized.

Why the stakes are high for cats

Report author Molly Hamilton, the Clean Label Project's executive director, told CNN that most cats eat the same food nearly every day, so contaminants represent an ongoing exposure that may accumulate in cats' bodies over their lifetimes.

She noted chronic kidney disease is among the most common causes of death in older cats, and kidneys play a major role in filtering heavy metals. Hamilton also said few regulations govern contaminants in pet food, with most guidelines designed for farm animals rather than house cats.

Industry pushback

The Pet Food Institute, which represents manufacturers, told CNN that its members implement comprehensive food safety and quality assurance programs, including ingredient specifications, supplier verification, testing protocols, traceability systems and science-based preventive controls.

CEO Elise Fennig said cat owners should feel confident their pets' food is safe and produced under rigorous regulatory and quality standards.

Ryan Babadi of Toxic Free Future, who was not involved, told CNN the analysis appeared reasonably conducted and said retailers should require suppliers to eliminate harmful chemicals.

What cat owners can do

The Clean Label Project recommends that owners whose cats favor seafood vary the diet with chicken or other proteins to limit mercury and cadmium exposure, since foods without fish in the name may still contain seafood ingredients.

Wet or air-dried products are preferable to dry food for lower lead exposure, per the report, and avoiding foods with many plant ingredients among the first ten may reduce glyphosate intake.

Above all, owners should ask manufacturers whether they regularly test finished products for heavy metals, the organization said.

Sources

  1. usatoday.com › Heavy metals found in 99% of cat foods tested in new study
  2. scrippsnews.com › Cat food investigation finds heavy metals, pesticides and plastic chemicals

More on Food