Former Utah Mail Carrier Indicted for Dumping 300 Ballots

A federal grand jury indicted former letter carrier Damon Matai Seei for allegedly tossing about 300 Utah mail-in ballots into a dumpster before a primary.

@sharedot

Former Utah Mail Carrier Indicted for Dumping 300 Ballots

By @sharedot · · 7 pages

  • US News
  • Elections
  • Justice
  • Utah

A federal grand jury indicted former letter carrier Damon Matai Seei for allegedly tossing about 300 Utah mail-in ballots into a dumpster before a primary.

What Happened

A federal grand jury indicted Damon Matai Seei, 34, of Payson, Utah, on September 16 on charges of unlawful secretion, destruction, and delay of mail after he allegedly threw away mail he was entrusted to deliver, including approximately 300 mail-in ballots sent to registered voters in Eagle Mountain, Utah.

According to court documents, Seei was working as a letter carrier on June 3, 2026, carrying mail to at least 300 Eagle Mountain residents, including ballots for the June 23 primary election. He allegedly discarded some of that mail into a dumpster in a church parking lot.

Seei was arrested and arraigned Tuesday at the Orrin G. Hatch U.S. Courthouse, where he entered a not guilty plea and was released on his own recognizance.

Why It Surprised Officials

The case surfaced not through a partisan complaint but through ordinary voter frustration.

FOX 13 News reports that earlier this summer, several Eagle Mountain residents claimed they could not vote in the June 23 primary because their ballots never arrived, and Utah County Clerk Aaron Davidson noticed the complaints clustered in House District 50.

According to NonStop Local, after voters complained, the clerk used county databases and found voter participation was remarkably low in the affected area.

Davidson alerted the USPS Office of Inspector General, and he told FOX 13 News he was surprised by the speed of the response — he expected a callback within 30 days but heard back the same day.

The Stated Motive, So Far

Federal officials did not announce a motive at Tuesday's media conference, but a government detention memo offers one account.

According to NonStop Local, Seei told investigators he had no political agenda and said he threw away other mail at the same time; the memo states he wanted to discard advertisements to "lighten his workload" after feeling overwhelmed.

The distinction matters: officials framed the case around ballot access rather than election manipulation. U.S. Attorney Melissa Holyoak said that when the defendant allegedly threw away the mail entrusted to him, he also threw away those citizens' chance to exercise their right to vote.

Acting Deputy Attorney General Trent McCotter called ballot integrity "not a partisan issue."

The Stakes for Voters

Roughly 300 registered voters in Eagle Mountain were potentially disenfranchised in a primary election, and it remains unclear whether the people who did not receive their ballots were eventually able to vote, NonStop Local reports.

The indictment lands amid heightened national attention on election administration: DOJ officials, Homeland Security Investigations, and the USPS Inspector General all emphasized the case was pursued to protect lawful voting.

Utah Lt. Gov. Deidre Henderson said she was grateful the department takes cases of denying lawful voting as seriously as alleged illegal voting.

The political backdrop is complicated — FOX 13 News notes Henderson is separately under a DOJ investigation over election records, even as she urges Utahns to use the state's ballot tracking service at trackmyballot.utah.gov.

What Comes Next

Seei's next court appearance is scheduled for November 30. The case was investigated jointly by the U.S. Postal Service Office of Inspector General and Homeland Security Investigations, with Assistant U.S. Attorney Todd C. Bouton for the District of Utah prosecuting.

USPS Assistant Inspector General Robert Kwalwasser said employees entrusted with delivering mail must uphold the highest standards of integrity and that those who destroy mail will be held accountable.

Officials stress the standard caveat: an indictment is merely an allegation, and the defendant is presumed innocent until proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. For Utah County voters, the case is likely to renew scrutiny of ballot delivery and tracking ahead of future elections.

Sources

  1. justice.gov › Former Postal Worker Indicted After Allegedly Disposing of Hundreds of Mail-In Ballots in Utah
  2. fox13now.com › Department of Justice files indictment against Utah postal worker for allegedly disposing of mail-in ballots
  3. kulr8.com › Former Utah postal worker indicted for tossing 300 mail-in ballots in Utah County

More on US News