Scientists Find Heme in 115M-Year-Old Dinosaur Bone

Researchers report the strongest evidence yet of fossilized red blood cells in an Aratasaurus bone, detecting heme in situ for the first time.

@sharedot

Scientists Find Heme in 115M-Year-Old Dinosaur Bone

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • Science
  • Paleontology
  • Dinosaurs
  • Fossils

Researchers report the strongest evidence yet of fossilized red blood cells in an Aratasaurus bone, detecting heme in situ for the first time.

A first: heme detected inside fossil blood-cell-like structures

According to CNN, the authors say it is the first time heme has been detected in situ, within the structures themselves, in a dinosaur fossil.

The Guardian quotes Grice calling it a world first: 'Fossilised red blood cells with distinct chemistry related to heme have never been found in situ in any fossil, let alone a dinosaur.'

The specimen: a juvenile theropod from Brazil

The fossil is a partial hind limb of *Aratasaurus museunacionali*, an Early Cretaceous theropod dug up in 2008 at the Mina Pedra Branca site in northeastern Brazil within the Romualdo Formation, a deposit famous for exceptionally preserved fossils.

CNN reports scientists believe stagnant waters limited oxygen and slowed decomposition there. Popular Science reports the juvenile dinosaur appears to have measured over 10 feet long and weighed about 75 pounds, and likely grew larger.

The remains have been held at Brazil's National Museum, where Grice's team sliced and analyzed the leg bone.

Multiple lines of evidence — and a mineral helper

The study combines new microscopic imaging and chemical analysis, bringing together the structures' location inside vascular canals, their appearance, mineral composition and chemical signals, CNN reports.

Chemical tests identified heme and its breakdown products, and The Guardian reports traces of the amino acid building blocks of collagen were also found.

The researchers suggest low-oxygen burial conditions limited organic breakdown, and that a manganese oxide called hausmannite formed in and around the cells, stabilizing and helping preserve them.

Grice says hausmannite is not considered an original cell component but a fossilization product that aided preservation.

Why experts are not fully convinced

Not everyone accepts the structures are red blood cells.

According to CNN, Mary Schweitzer of North Carolina State University says the findings do not meet established standards for identifying fossilized blood cells, questioning whether shape and size match red blood cells in living dinosaur relatives and the significance of hausmannite, which is not detected in living red blood cells.

The Guardian reports her specific objection: the cells should show a 'nuclear bulge' making them dome-like, while the structures found are concave.

Still, Schweitzer says the multiple-technique approach is an exciting advancement and she is hopeful some dinosaur molecules remain preserved in the bone.

Not Jurassic Park: heme is not DNA

The discovery does not bring science closer to recreating dinosaur DNA.

CNN reports that Timothy Cleland, a physical scientist at the Smithsonian Institution's Museum Conservation Institute, explained heme and DNA are different molecules that fossilize in bone in different ways, so finding evidence of one does not mean the other survived.

Grice also urges caution, telling The Guardian that 'any extraordinary claim needs extraordinary analytical evidence,' and that the aim is not Jurassic Park DNA but determining how much genuine molecular information deep time can preserve.

The stakes are instead physiological: understanding dinosaur oxygen transport, metabolism and tissue function.

Next: testing museum drawers worldwide

Grice's team plans to expand the research to other fossils across species, geological time periods and environments to learn how widespread such molecular preservation might be, CNN reports.

She raises a striking possibility: similar preservation may simply have been overlooked, meaning fossils sitting in museum collections around the world could contain unexamined cellular and molecular information.

Cleland asks whether the preservation extends beyond this one dinosaur to other species in the Romualdo Formation and other exceptional sites, per CNN. Popular Science adds that if delicate biomolecules survive deep time, similar traces of life might even linger elsewhere in the universe.

Sources

  1. cnn.com › Scientists say they've found rare evidence of blood cells in a fossil
  2. theguardian.com › Fossilised red blood cells found in 115m-year-old dinosaur's bone
  3. popsci.com › Dinosaur blood found in fossils for the first time

More on Science