Climate Change Outpowered El Niño in Turbocharging Hurricane Polo
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- Climate
- Hurricanes
- El Nino
- Extreme Weather
- Attribution Science
A rapid attribution study finds global warming, not record El Niño, was the bigger force pushing Pacific Hurricane Polo to record Category 5 strength.
A storm that broke the Pacific's records
Hurricane Polo, which formed in late September off Mexico's Pacific coast, exploded from a tropical storm to Category 5 — winds above 252 km/h — in roughly 24 hours.
According to EL PAÍS, it was the second most powerful tropical cyclone recorded in the Pacific to date, and the Associated Press reports it set the Pacific record for time spent at Category 5, holding that intensity for two and a half days.
Polo later weakened before making landfall as a Category 2 storm in Baja California Sur, leaving torrential rains, floods and infrastructure damage across northwest Mexico and the southwestern United States, with five deaths linked to flooding in Mexico.
The surprise: warming beat El Niño
The striking finding from the joint World Weather Attribution and Climate Central study, published October 14, is that human-caused global warming outdid even this year's super-strong El Niño.
According to the Associated Press, the burning of coal, oil and gas added about 6 mph (nearly 10 kph) to Polo's strength, while El Niño contributed a bit less, about 5 mph (8 kph).
That ordering surprised University at Albany atmospheric scientist Brian Tang, who was not part of the study, given how extreme this El Niño is — but he noted that from a long-term standpoint the result is less unexpected.
How the teams measured it
Both research teams used the accepted attribution method of comparing the real, warmer world against a hypothetical world that has not warmed by 1.4 degrees Celsius since pre-industrial times.
They found climate change made the conditions fueling Polo roughly 23 times more likely, while El Niño made them 14 times more likely. The storm rode ocean water of 31.2 degrees Celsius — up to 2 degrees Celsius above normal.
Per IndexBox, the teams measured conditions somewhat differently but reached the same overall conclusion, boosting confidence; however, the rapid study has not yet been peer-reviewed.
Co-author Daniel Gilford likened the dynamics to driving: in the Pacific, El Niño's wind shear acts as a green light, and water warmed by both factors floors the accelerator.
Why the finding matters
Study co-author Friederike Otto, who coordinates World Weather Attribution, said El Niño comes and goes but climate change only worsens — meaning every future East Pacific hurricane now carries at least this climate change signal, and it will grow as fossil fuel burning continues.
Kristina Dahl, vice president of science at Climate Central, called the study a powerful reminder that while El Niño is shifting hazards around the globe, the dominant signal behind it all remains climate change.
Outside scientists including Jeff Masters of Yale Climate Connections, Michael Mann and Carl Schreck told the Associated Press they believe the study understates warming's contribution, pointing to Gilford's own 2024 work that found climate change added 30 kph to Atlantic hurricanes from 2019 to 2023.
Lives saved, warnings vindicated
Despite Polo's explosive intensification at sea, EL PAÍS reports that human losses stayed small thanks to a successful emergency response and because the storm struck a sparsely populated region.
Researchers stressed the importance of early warning systems as extreme events become more frequent, more intense, or both.
UN climate chief Simon Stiell, cited by EL PAÍS, said El Niño is already raising the risk level for the Pacific hurricane season, and that the study shows climate change is increasing the danger and costs of storms as humanity keeps burning coal, oil and gas — arguing the answer is to accelerate the clean energy transition and invest in resilient infrastructure.
What comes next
The Associated Press notes this year, with a super-strong El Niño, has set records for the strength and longevity of Pacific storms, and Polo's two-and-a-half days at Category 5 is the benchmark now on the books.
The relationship between El Niño and climate change remains under study, with no clear conclusions about warming's role in the cyclical event itself — though Imperial College London researcher and WWA investigator Ben Clarke pointed out that every El Niño now occurs in a warmer world.
Separately, a NASA-funded study reported by BBC Sky at Night Magazine found melting ice and groundwater loss are slowing Earth's spin and lengthening days by 1.33 milliseconds per century since 2000, the fastest change in the previous century — a measure of how deeply emissions are reshaping the planet.
Sources
- english.elpais.com › Climate change and El Niño pushed explosive hurricane 'Polo' to the highest category
- whec.com › Study says global warming did more than El Niño to turbocharge Hurricane Polo
- indexbox.io › Climate Change and El Nino Intensified Hurricane Polo, Study Finds
- skyatnightmagazine.com › Climate change slows Earth's spin, makes days longer