Did the Young Sun Swallow a Super-Earth Named Dev Dilek?
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- Science
- Astronomy
- The Sun
- Exoplanets
- Super Earth
New modelling suggests the young Sun may have consumed a rocky super-Earth five to ten times Earth's mass, leaving fingerprints still hidden inside it today.
A star with a planetary meal on its conscience
New research by astronomer Mutlu Yildiz of Ege University in Turkey suggests the young Sun may have swallowed a rocky planet several times more massive than Earth early in its history, leaving a lasting chemical imprint deep inside the star.
The study, published in the Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, builds on earlier work proposing that a super-Earth could have formed near the orbit of Mercury and migrated inward through the protoplanetary disc before crashing into the young Sun.
The hypothetical planet has been informally named 'Dev Dilek' — Turkish for 'Great Wish.' The scenario could also explain why our solar system lacks a super-Earth, a planet type common around other stars.
Why the idea is surprising
The surprising outcome is how specifically the calculations converged. 'We thought planetary engulfment might affect the solar structure but did not expect the calculations to converge on such a specific super-Earth mass range,' Yildiz said in a statement.
According to Space, the best fit for the Sun's current characteristics was the consumption of a planet between five and ten times Earth's mass — a super-Earth.
SpaceDaily reports that the preferred model centres near 5.6 Earth masses, and that when the Sun's lithium depletion is included, the acceptable interval tightens to roughly 4.6 to 5.8 Earth masses.
The convergence matters because the improved fit is not simply explained by the engulfment models having more adjustable parameters, according to SpaceDaily.
Two solar mysteries, one hypothesis
The hypothesis addresses two long-standing puzzles at once: discrepancies between standard solar models and observations of the Sun's interior — including the depth of the convection zone and the sound-speed structure just below it — and the Sun's strikingly low surface lithium.
Mashable notes the Sun's surface has over 100 times less lithium than expected from the material it formed from, and that lithium atoms only break apart deep inside a star where it is much hotter.
In the engulfment scenario, a compact, lithium-poor, heavy-element-rich planet dissolves and settles below the convection zone, improving the helioseismic fit while accounting for the missing lithium, according to SpaceDaily.
Could a rocky planet survive the plunge?
A major objection is whether a planet diving into a star would be torn apart before delivering its material to the right depth.
According to SpaceDaily, Yildiz tested feasibility using Roche-lobe stability, high-pressure planet structures, and drag and ablation estimates, finding that a compact, core-dominated rocky planet could reach the solar surface without complete tidal disruption.
Mashable reports that in the simulations the planet shrinks under intense pressure, exposing a smaller area to the gas and losing only a fraction of its mass before reaching the base of the convection zone — so most of its rocky core could end up exactly where the models need it.
SpaceDaily cautions this is a plausibility argument, not a full simulation of the ingestion.
What the stakes are
If confirmed, the finding would rewrite the early history of the solar system: super-Earths are among the most common exoplanet types, yet none orbits our Sun, and this scenario suggests the missing world may have existed — and been destroyed.
According to BigGo Finance, a 2018 analysis of Kepler data concluded that about 30% of Sun-like stars host a close-in super-Earth.
The paper does not claim definitive proof, only that a Sun with an early planetary feast matches a wide range of measurements better than any model without one, per Mashable. Primetimer adds the model does not even require a planet to have been totally engulfed.
What comes next: hunting the fingerprints
The evidence for now is indirect — computer modelling and unexplained solar features rather than any direct detection — as Primetimer and SpaceDaily both note.
The decisive test would be independently identifying the predicted composition gradient and sound-speed structure, then showing that ordinary adjustments to opacity, abundances and mixing cannot reproduce them as well, SpaceDaily reports.
'The next step is to see if these fingerprints can be independently detected,' Yildiz concluded.
BigGo Finance notes the instruments largely already exist: the National Science Foundation's Global Oscillation Network Group and NASA's Solar Dynamics Observatory already probe the solar interior quantities the paper identifies as the place to look.
Sources
- space.com › The sun may once have swallowed a super-Earth planet and could still be hiding the evidence
- mashable.com › The sun may have eaten a missing super-Earth, new study suggests
- spacedaily.com › Young Sun swallowed super-Earth: chemical, helioseismic fingerprints
- finance.biggo.com › The Sun May Have Swallowed a Super-Earth Billions of Years Ago, Astronomers Say
- primetimer.com › The Sun may have eaten a super-Earth planet billions of years ago