Ciara Miller Out at 21 as Guillermo Survives on 13
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- Celebrity
- Dancing With The Stars
- Reality Tv
Mariah Carey Night on DWTS sent Ciara Miller home despite a 21/30, while Guillermo Rodriguez survived the night's lowest score of 13, outlets report.
The Upset: Second-Shock Elimination
The Hollywood Reporter and today.com both report that Ciara Miller and Brandon Armstrong were eliminated at the end of Mariah Carey Night on Tuesday, October 6, marking the second consecutive week DWTS ended with a shocking result after Taylor Hanson and Britt Stewart went home on Yacht Rock Night.
What makes the outcome an upset, per Bergen Record/USA TODAY Network coverage, is that Miller scored 21/30 with a jazz to "Emotions" — tied for fifth on the night's leaderboard and ahead of several couples who survived with lower judges' scores.
Elimination is decided by the combined total of judges' scores and viewer votes, and Miller's totals fell short despite her mid-table performance. The cast shrank from 12 celebrities to 11.
Why It's Surprising: Votes Beat Scores
The starkest reversal of the night, as The Hollywood Reporter and today.com describe it, is that Guillermo Rodriguez and Witney Carson landed at the very bottom of the leaderboard with just 13/30 for their samba to "Obsessed" — yet survived.
Bruno Tonioli joked it was "more shamble than samba," while Derek Hough told Rodriguez, "I'm obsessed with you," and Carrie Ann Inaba encouraged him to let his natural joy shine, Bergen Record reports.
The split between the scoreboard and the fan vote underscores how much popularity — Rodriguez has become a fan favorite — now outweighs technical marks on season 35.
The Evidence: Season-Best at the Top
Multiple outlets (The Hollywood Reporter, today.com, Bergen Record) list the full Mariah Carey Night leaderboard: Maura Higgins and Mark Ballas led with 25/30 for a Waltz to "If It's Over" — the highest score of season 35 and the first nine paddle of the season, awarded by Carrie Ann Inaba.
Ezra Frech, Harry Shum Jr. and Jenna Dewan each earned 24/30, with three couples opening the night on 24/30. Amber Glenn and Pasha Pashkov scored 23; Tyler Cameron, Jackson Olson, Julia Stiles and Ciara Miller all landed on 21; Tatyana Ali scored 20, Connor Wood 19, and Guillermo Rodriguez 13.
Breakthrough Moments the Judges Loved
Yahoo (citing TheWrap) reports that Mariah Carey herself sent a video message cheering contestants on, and that the judges were moved by several breakthroughs: Jenna Dewan showed a "vulnerable" side in a rumba to "My All" that drew "there she is" from Derek Hough, while Ezra Frech wowed with a promenade turn on his prosthetic leg in a rumba to "Anytime You Need a Friend" that Hough called "seriously sophisticated."
Carrie Ann Inaba said she was stunned by the level of competition, per The Hollywood Reporter. Inaba also became emotional watching Higgins and Ballas, calling their waltz "excellent, excellent, excellent," Bergen Record reports.
Off the Floor: Olson's Apology and the Tour
Two storylines swirled around the episode. E!
News reports that Jackson Olson publicly apologized on Instagram on October 6 to Guillermo Rodriguez over a since-deleted comment that appeared to mock Rodriguez's dancing, writing, "from the bottom of my heart I am so sorry about my comment," in a video set to Hannah Montana's "Nobody's Perfect" that ended with Rodriguez dancing alongside him.
Separately, Us Weekly reports Emma Slater announced the Dancing With the Stars 2027 live tour after Tuesday's show: a Mandy Moore-directed, 60-city North American arena run with presale starting October 8 and general tickets October 13, and for the first time the troupe joining the pros.
What Comes Next: Super Bowl Night
Eleven celebrities remain chasing the Len Goodman Mirrorball Trophy, per Bergen Record's list: Guillermo Rodriguez, Amber Glenn, Harry Shum Jr., Jackson Olson, Tatyana Ali, Ezra Frech, Connor Wood, Tyler Cameron, Jenna Dewan, Maura Higgins and Julia Stiles.
Season 35 airs Tuesdays at 8 p.m. simulcast on ABC and Disney+, streaming next day on Hulu, The Hollywood Reporter notes.
Next Tuesday, October 13 brings Super Bowl Night, with routines inspired by past Super Bowl halftime show songs, appearances by NFL legends and a surprise guest judge, Bergen Record and today.com report.
Voting — up to 10 votes per couple per method — happens live during the East Coast airing, which is precisely the mechanism that just decided two straight weeks of shock exits.
Sources
- hollywoodreporter.com › 'Dancing With the Stars' Mariah Carey Night Ends With Another Unexpected Elimination, Season 35's Highest Score Yet
- northjersey.com › Who went home on 'Dancing with the Stars' tonight? Who was eliminated?
- today.com › Mariah Carey Night on 'DWTS' Leaves 1 Couple Eliminated and Heartbroken
- yahoo.com › 'DWTS' Week 4: Maura Higgins' 'Exquisite' Waltz Earns Top Score on Mariah Carey Night
- eonline.com › Dancing With the Stars' Jackson Olson Apologizes for Guillermo Rodriguez Comment
- usmagazine.com › 'Dancing With the Stars' Announces 2027 Tour Details: See Which Pros Are Hitting the Road