UK Celebrity Loses Anonymity Fight Despite Suicide Warning
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- Celebrity
- UK Celebrity Injunction
- Legal News
- Media Law
A British celebrity accused of sexual misconduct lost his High Court injunction bid but stays anonymous pending a possible appeal.
What Happened in Court
At London's High Court on Tuesday, Mr. Justice Nicklin dismissed the claim brought by an unidentified male celebrity seeking to stop ITN and Guardian News and Media from publishing sexual misconduct allegations and his identity.
"The claim brought by the claimant is dismissed and the application for the injunction is refused," the judge ruled, per Page Six.
However, an interim injunction protecting his anonymity remains in place while he decides whether to appeal, and the judge stressed that the court did not determine whether any of the allegations are true.
Why the Ruling Is So Unusual
This case is a rare reversal: a celebrity asked judges to suppress an investigation not over truth of the allegations, but because he says publication would be "highly likely" to lead him to kill himself.
According to BBC News, no prior case establishes that a court's knowledge of suicide risk, together with its power to prohibit the event expected to increase it, is by itself enough to require the court to act.
Variety notes the case has sparked widespread speculation about his identity and concern over press freedom ramifications.
The Court Heard About Two Suicide Attempts
His lawyer, Sara Mansoori KC, told the court that publication "would have a potentially fatal impact," saying the man had attempted suicide twice after being contacted by news outlets, was hospitalized for months, detained involuntarily, and examined by more than 10 doctors, Page Six reports.
She argued the only reason the attempts would not be fatal is that he "would be locked up and prevented from his desire to end his life." The BBC says the judge accepted publication would cause "acute and potentially prolonged mental suffering" but found no legal duty to restrain it.
The Allegations and the Media's Investigation
The allegations involve claims that the celebrity abused "power and status" to contact young women and pursue "inappropriate and exploitative sexual activities" over several years, including potential criminal activity, which he vehemently denies.
Gavin Millar KC, representing ITN and the Guardian, argued the outlets conducted a "wide-ranging and rigorous investigation," speaking to more than 100 people, and that alleged victims have been traumatized and suffered mental health crises, per BBC News and Yahoo.
"The obligation falls on the hospital to keep him safe, and that's that," Millar told the court.
The Legal Stakes for Privacy Law
As Yahoo explains, the UK has no First Amendment equivalent; judges must balance Article 8 privacy rights against Article 10 freedom of expression under the European Convention on Human Rights.
The claimant also cited Article 2, the right to life — an unusual step University of Leeds media law professor Paul Wragg told Yahoo makes the balancing process "slightly more complicated."
Justice Nicklin rejected the right-to-life argument, writing that a permanent injunction "would have been an exceptionally serious restriction upon freedom of expression," while acknowledging publication would interfere "exceptionally seriously" with his private and family life.
What Comes Next
The interim anonymity order remains in force, and it would be against the law to identify him or publish details that might do so — TMZ reports the judge previously warned the public they could end up behind bars for trying.
His lawyer said he is "in a highly vulnerable position" and cannot give instructions yet; the BBC reports he must lodge reasons to appeal by 16:30 GMT on November 9. Litigator Dan Tench told Yahoo he expects a Court of Appeal decision quickly, "possibly even next week."
Sources
- pagesix.com › 'Suicidal' celeb accused of sexual misconduct denied bid to hide ID — why he still won't be named
- bbc.com › Celebrity loses injunction bid but will stay anonymous pending appeal
- variety.com › U.K. Celebrity Loses Injunction Bid to Prevent Sexual Misconduct Allegations From Being Published, but Will Remain Anonymous Pending Appeal
- yahoo.com › U.K. celebrity accused of sexual misconduct loses legal battle to keep identity secret despite risk of suicide. What happens next?
- tmz.com › UK Celebrity Can't Maintain Anonymity in Sexual Misconduct Case, Judge Rules