Clayface Wins, But Holmes Doc's Second Weekend Surges

DC's 'Clayface' took No. 1 with a $24 million debut, but A24's Elizabeth Holmes documentary surged 25% to $19.5M in a rare second-weekend jump.

@sharedot

Clayface Wins, But Holmes Doc's Second Weekend Surges

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • Entertainment
  • Box Office

DC's 'Clayface' took No. 1 with a $24 million debut, but A24's Elizabeth Holmes documentary surged 25% to $19.5M in a rare second-weekend jump.

'Clayface' Claims No. 1 While the Holmes Doc Refuses to Fade

DC Studios' R-rated 'Clayface' debuted in first place with $24 million across 3,458 North American theaters, according to studio estimates reported by the Associated Press and France 24, edging A24's Elizabeth Holmes documentary 'You Can See Everything,' which pulled in $19.5 million in second.

Deadline pegs Clayface's opening at $24.5 million with a $43 million global start, and reports that the combined Paramount and Warner Bros. operation has now topped the domestic box office for two straight weeks.

Why the Documentary's Surge Is the Real Story

The surprise is that 'You Can See Everything' grew in its second wide-release frame instead of dropping. Gross.

France 24 notes the weekend ranks as the second-biggest ever for a documentary, behind only 2004's 'Fahrenheit 9/11.' With $45.1 million in two weeks, the AP says it already ranks among the highest-grossing documentaries ever — and A24 reportedly spent just $7 million making it.

The Platform Play Behind the Momentum

A24 deliberately opened 'You Can See Everything' in fewer than 1,000 theaters to build buzz through sellouts before going wide, and Deadline reports that one non-A24 distribution head argued the industry should use this kind of 'tease' platforming more often.

The film, a three-hour documentary co-directed by Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim, follows Holmes and her family at home in 2023 during the month before she began an 11-year prison sentence for defrauding Theranos investors.

Deadline also credits a continuing meme craze and a CBS News interview with whistleblower Tyler Shultz as free marketing the film didn't pay for.

Clayface Wins on Its Own Modest Terms

A $24 million opening would have been a flop for most superhero films, the AP notes, but 'Clayface' cost only $44 million to produce — a fraction of typical comic book budgets — and added $19 million internationally for a $43 million worldwide start, per IGN.

That assured profitability offers stability to DC Studios after 'Supergirl' grossed just $126 million worldwide on a $170 million budget.

IGN reports the James Watkins-directed film, written by Mike Flanagan and Hossein Amini and starring Tom Rhys Harries as Matt Hagen, earned an 'A-' CinemaScore, a grade James Gunn said on Threads is nearly unheard of in horror, alongside 'Obsession,' 'Weapons' and 'Get Out' (per Deadline) — with IGN adding a 75% critics score and 94% audience score on Rotten Tomatoes.

Awards Season Stakes for a Three-Hour Doc

The AP reports that 'You Can See Everything' has become a sensation partly by drawing waves of Gen Z moviegoers, and that if it earns a Best Picture nomination at the Oscars it would be the first documentary ever nominated for Hollywood's top prize.

France 24 adds that Amanda Seyfried's surprise cameo has sparked awards chatter. Analysts quoted by the AP call it a zeitgeist film about money, dreams, truth and reality, and Deadline reports some in the industry see an $80 million North American endgame.

The stakes now run both ways: a low-budget genre experiment proving DC can profit modestly, and a documentary rewriting what nonfiction can do theatrically.

The Rest of the Chart and What Comes Next

Laika's stop-motion 'Wildwood' debuted third with $11.8 million on an 'A' CinemaScore — well above the $6-8 million range Hollywood Outbreak says was expected, though its $100 million budget still makes profit unlikely, analysts tell the AP.

'Street Fighter' collapsed 72% to $8.6 million in week two, and Black Bear's 'Wicker' opened fifth at $5.8 million from just 1,471 theaters.

The AP also flags flops elsewhere: Taika Waititi's 'Klara and the Sun' managed just $725,000, while Amazon MGM didn't report grosses for Sacha Baron Cohen's 'Ali G: Who Iz I?'.

Next weekend brings a Halloween frame that Deadline warns could be disastrous for business overall, with both 'Clayface' and the Holmes doc's holding power the questions to watch.

Sources

  1. aol.com › 'You Can See Everything' surges with $19.5M at box office; 'Clayface' takes No. 1
  2. france24.com › Villain intrigue: 'Clayface', Holmes doc lead N. America box office
  3. deadline.com › Box Office: 'Clayface' No 1 With $24M+, 'You Can See Everything' At Near $20M
  4. in.ign.com › Clayface Looks Like a Win for the DCU After Earning $43 Million in Box Office Opening Weekend
  5. hollywoodoutbreak.com › 'Clayface' Wins Weekend Box Office as Holmes Doc Surges

More on Entertainment