Fenty, Glow Recipe and Huda All Launch the Same Eye Patches

Three major beauty brands debuted identical twist-and-dispense hydrogel eye patches within days, and Cosmopolitan says being first no longer matters.

@sharedot

Fenty, Glow Recipe and Huda All Launch the Same Eye Patches

By @sharedot · · 7 pages

  • Beauty
  • Eye Patches
  • Brand Drama

Three major beauty brands debuted identical twist-and-dispense hydrogel eye patches within days, and Cosmopolitan says being first no longer matters.

What Happened: One Tube, Three Brands, Days Apart

According to Cosmopolitan, the week's beauty chaos began when Fenty Beauty teased its Dew N Plump Fresh-Sliced Hydrogel Eye Patches, touting a "first of its kind" tub that dispenses and cuts off a fresh slice of hydrogel when twisted.

The very next day, Glow Recipe sent influencers a package featuring the same twist-and-dispense tube for its new Exopeptide Caffeine Brightening and Depuffing Fresh Slices Eye Mask.

Hours later, Huda Beauty announced its first-ever skincare product, Undereye Jelly Patches, in what Cosmopolitan describes as the exact same tube design. Bubble, Vitamasques and Wonderskin also posted about working on their own versions.

Why It's Surprising: Everyone Used the Same Manufacturer

Cosmopolitan's reporting suggests the awkward triple-launch happened because all three brands evidently worked with the same manufacturer and may each have been told they would be first to market.

The magazine notes commenters immediately seized on the timeline — "Fenty, then Glow Recipe, then Huda!!!! Who's next?" one wrote on creator Prableen Kaur Bhomrah's Huda announcement — and TikTok filled with reaction videos speculating about founder beef.

Adding to the drama, Molly Sims posted a teary-eyed video accusing another founder of copying her YISE Beauty Wide Awake Brightening Eye Cream, which viewers matched to Jones Road's similarly named concealer, compounding claims that the industry lacks true innovation.

The Evidence: The Feuds Fizzled Fast

Cosmopolitan reports the confrontation largely dissolved behind the scenes: Sims said on her Instagram Stories that she and Jones Road founder Bobbi Brown worked through their issues privately, and Fenty and Huda Beauty collaborated on an Instagram post joking about the packaging kerfuffle, which People Brands and Things covered as a reaction campaign.

The magazine's beauty editor also notes she has tested both Wide Awake products — YISE's is a tinted, your-skin-but-better eye cream in four shades, while Jones Road's is a true concealer in a wide range — and found them quite different.

Cosmopolitan also points out the packaging was never custom to these brands in the first place.

The Stakes: First to Market May Not Win

Cosmopolitan argues the whole spectacle distracts from what actually drives purchases: performance.

The editor writes she does not care who did it first, only who does it best, and wants reviews of whether fresh-cut hydrogel is genuinely more hygienic or better for depuffing rather than fanfare about innovation.

She notes YISE Beauty likely has not secured a trademark on the name "Wide Awake," that dupes are celebrated in beauty now — potentially making it a detriment to be the OG — and that shoppers will probably buy from brands they already trust or whatever is cheapest in this economy.

What Comes Next: Performance Over Hype

Cosmopolitan says the formulas' real worth remains to be seen, with eye-patch reviews pending to settle whether any version lives up to the hoopla.

The copycat-panic moment also echoes a broader critique running through the niche: Creative Boom reports that agency Uncommon won a D&AD Black Pencil for The Ordinary's "Periodic Fable" campaign, which catalogued 49 meaningless beauty buzzwords like "elixir" and "age-defying" — terms Creative Boom says make 2016 blurbs feel like AI slop — and drove an 11.8x traffic spike, 80-plus press pieces and a 10.4% rise in purchase intent among American women.

Fans should watch whether shoppers reward originality or simply the best formula.

Sources

  1. cosmopolitan.com › Beauty Brands Are Fighting Over Who Did It First. But Does That Actually Matter?
  2. creativeboom.com › Beauty brands were writing slop before AI: how Uncommon won a D&AD Black Pencil

More on Beauty