Critics Sharply Split Over Swift's 'Showgirl: The Encore'

Taylor Swift's four-track deluxe 'The Life of a Showgirl: The Encore' arrived Sept. 25 to wildly divided reviews, from 'superb' to 'terrible.'

@sharedot

Critics Sharply Split Over Swift's 'Showgirl: The Encore'

By @sharedot · · 7 pages

  • Entertainment
  • Music
  • Taylor Swift
  • Album Reviews

Taylor Swift's four-track deluxe 'The Life of a Showgirl: The Encore' arrived Sept. 25 to wildly divided reviews, from 'superb' to 'terrible.'

What Happened: Four New Songs Arrive

Taylor Swift released The Life of a Showgirl: The Encore on Friday, Sept. 25, a deluxe edition of her 12th studio album adding four songs — "Patient Zero," "Pink Clouding," "Babylon" and "Cleveland!" — all written after the original album dropped.

Billboard reports the project followed a week of Easter eggs, from a cryptic Emmys Law & Order: SVU spoof moment to zeros appearing in her Instagram bio and a website countdown.

Swift said in her announcement that a celebratory trip to Sweden with collaborators Max Martin and Shellback turned into new material: "there was a studio there and we did what we do when we feel anything at all: We wrote more songs."

Why It's Surprising: A Stark Critical Divide

Reviews landed across a remarkable range. The Irish Times called The Encore "superb," while The Telegraph ran a viral two-star takedown headlined "I'm a Swiftie and even I think these new songs are terrible."

According to AOL, Telegraph culture writer Poppie Platt found the four tracks "just as derivative and flat" as the original 12, and singled out "Cleveland!" as more rooted in public perception than inner feeling.

The Guardian, meanwhile, framed the batch as "sweet highs and galling lows," praising flashes of humanity while calling the Kelce love songs bafflingly vindictive. Few major releases have produced such a spread of verdicts in a single day.

The Evidence: Track-by-Track Reactions

Billboard ranked "Cleveland!" first, calling the Travis Kelce tribute transparent and fun, with the line "The taste of me is acquired, but it's his favorite dish."

The Guardian disagrees sharply, reporting that Cleveland! is "appalling" and a "cut-and-shut" of her worst impulses, though the Guardian names "Patient Zero" the standout, with its mournful Celtic fiddle sample and connection to a woman burned by an ex.

The Independent, per AOL, called "Babylon" a "diamond" but the other three songs "duds," while USA Today praised "Patient Zero" as an omniscient take on a soured relationship and said the reissue deserves an ovation.

The Stakes: Chart Strategy and Creative Fatigue

The Guardian notes fans suspected the deluxe was timed to remind Grammy voters during the nomination window or to displace Ella Langley from her record-breaking US No. 1 run — especially since Swift had promised Showgirl would never be expanded, even as she released 34 variants to juice sales.

The Guardian argues the more Swift releases, the weaker the output gets, and that the healthiest thing for her creativity would be to "let the curtain fall for a while."

Billboard notes the parent album spent 12 weeks at No. 1 and set the biggest opening sales week in the modern age, so the commercial stakes remain enormous regardless of reviews.

What Comes Next: 'Patient Zero' Video at VMAs

Billboard reports "Patient Zero," the focus single, will get a cinematic music video starring Colin Farrell and Dakota Johnson, premiering at the 2026 VMAs. Swift framed the songs as "born out of pure gratitude" for fan enthusiasm.

The question critics leave open is whether goodwill and chart momentum can outrun the fatigue they describe: Variety, per AOL, found the tracks prove she has no intention of turning in her "Tortured Poets membership card," and called the release refreshing precisely because it is fast and easily digestible between pop opuses.

Whether the Swifties push The Encore back to No. 1 until Christmas, as the Guardian speculates, may settle the argument.

Sources

  1. billboard.com › All 4 New Songs on Taylor Swift's 'The Life of a Showgirl: The Encore' Ranked
  2. aol.com › Taylor Swift's 'The Life of a Showgirl: The Encore' Divides Critics: Is It 'Terrible' or 'Superb'?
  3. theguardian.com › Taylor Swift: The Life of a Showgirl: The Encore review – flashes of humanity and bafflingly vindictive love songs

More on Entertainment