Supreme Court Blocks Missouri GOP Map for November Election

The Supreme Court blocked Missouri's newly drawn Republican congressional map on Thursday, restoring the 2022 districts for the November midterms.

@sharedot

Supreme Court Blocks Missouri GOP Map for November Election

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • US News
  • Missouri Redistricting
  • Supreme Court

The Supreme Court blocked Missouri's newly drawn Republican congressional map on Thursday, restoring the 2022 districts for the November midterms.

What Happened

The U.S. Supreme Court on Thursday blocked an attempt by Missouri Secretary of State Denny Hoskins to use a newly drawn Republican congressional map in this year's elections.

In a brief unsigned order with no noted dissents, the court granted an emergency request from People Not Politicians, led by activist Richard von Glahn, and stayed a ruling by U.S. District Judge Stephen Clark, who had ordered Tuesday that the new map must be used.

The order did not detail the court's legal reasoning, as is typical in emergency appeals.

Why It Matters

The swift action likely signals the end of a battle over which map Missouri uses in the November midterms, with the state likely to revert to the 2022 map that includes six Republican-held and two Democratic-held seats.

The new map sought to eliminate the Kansas City-based seat of Rep. Emanuel Cleaver and could have produced a 7-1 Republican delegation, a gain of one seat in a nationwide redistricting push led by President Trump aimed at holding the GOP's slim House majority.

A Week of Dueling Orders

The fight bounced between courts within a single week. The Missouri Supreme Court ruled Sept. 3 that the 2025 map never took effect because it was suspended by a valid referendum petition with more than 300,000 signatures.

Justice Brett Kavanaugh rejected Hoskins' bid to block that ruling Tuesday, but minutes later Clark issued a 14-day temporary restraining order requiring the new map, reasoning that switching lines after the August primary could disenfranchise voters.

The Eighth Circuit declined to stay Clark's order, sending the case back to Kavanaugh and then the full court.

Election Clock Pressures

The timing was acute: Missouri's first ballots are set to go out Sept. 19, and Hoskins' lawyers warned the justices minutes before the decision that only Clark's order was 'preventing the disenfranchisement of hundreds of thousands of voters' who participated in the primary under the new map.

The Trump administration filed a brief backing Hoskins, saying blocking Clark's ruling would 'jeopardize state officials' ability to conduct a timely and lawful federal election.'

Contempt Fight Continues

The ruling came the same morning Hoskins appeared before the Missouri Supreme Court for a contempt hearing over defying its order.

Chief Justice Brent Powell told Hoskins not to 'venture far from Jefferson City' while the court weighs the motion and pressed him to issue updated guidance to local election officials, saying 'we just want to make sure the law is followed.'

According to NBC News, Hoskins' lawyer said his client would comply with the state order 'unless and until' an intervening federal decision, and is still evaluating next steps.

What Comes Next

Thursday's order stays Clark's ruling while the appeal proceeds in the Eighth Circuit, and the stay ends automatically if the Supreme Court ultimately declines to hear the case, per Missouri Independent.

Under the state ruling now back in effect, voters will decide Proposition A on the Nov. 3 ballot: if rejected, the 2022 districts remain in place; if approved, the new map can take effect after the election.

Analyst Shawn Donahue told Straight Arrow that a big open question remains which candidates will appear on the general election ballot.

Sources

  1. nbcnews.com › Supreme Court blocks Missouri's attempt to use newly drawn Republican congressional map
  2. spectrumlocalnews.com › U.S. Supreme Court throws out Missouri congressional maps backed by Trump
  3. cbsnews.com › Supreme Court blocks Missouri from using new map favoring GOP in midterm elections
  4. sgfcitizen.org › US Supreme Court again blocks use of Missouri's gerrymandered congressional map
  5. san.com › SCOTUS blocks Missouri from using newly-drawn congressional map

More on US News