SEC Sides With CFTC in Stock Perpetual Futures Lawsuit
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- Crypto
- Regulation
- Cftc
- SEC
- Perpetual Futures
The SEC filed a brief defending the CFTC's approval of single-stock perpetual futures as an industry group including Cboe and Citadel sues.
SEC Breaks Ranks to Defend the CFTC
The SEC filed an amicus brief in the Southern District of New York supporting the CFTC's approval of perpetual futures on individual US stocks, rebuffing the Capital Markets Alliance Association's claim that its sister agency acted alone.
The SEC said the CMAA's portrayal of 'a CFTC gone rogue, and an SEC gone missing' is mistaken, noting both agencies jointly sought comment on the products and that exchanges filed related documents with the SEC.
Notably, the brief does not say whether the contracts are futures or swaps, a gap the alliance's Tuesday reply flagged as showing the SEC has not yet decided.
Crypto Briefing reports the suit was filed November 3 by the industry group, whose members include Cboe and Citadel Securities, against the CFTC and Chairman Michael S. Selig.
Why a Regulator Backing a Regulator Is the Surprise
The lawsuit argues these contracts are security-based swaps that belong under SEC jurisdiction — yet the SEC itself told the court it backs the CFTC's approval.
Security futures already sit in a rare joint-oversight arrangement under the Commodity Futures Modernization Act of 2000, and the SEC's support suggests the agencies are comfortable sharing it for now.
The intervention cuts directly against the plaintiffs' framing that these products are the SEC's to approve.
The Product and the Delivery Argument
Perpetual futures drop the expiration date that defines traditional futures, letting positions stay open indefinitely with a funding rate keeping prices tied to the underlying stock.
The CMAA argues a contract with no expiration never creates a delivery obligation, so calling it a future stretches the definition past its breaking point.
BigGo Finance reports the six defending firms countered that the Commodity Exchange Act's definition of security futures does not require delivery on a specific date, and that payments based on a funding rate constitute delivery of rights based on the stock's value.
They added that Dodd-Frank's 2010 definition of security-based swaps explicitly excluded security futures.
The Court's Early Signals Cut Both Ways
According to Finance Magnates, Judge Valerie Caproni handled the emergency request on November 3 and found the alliance likely to show the CFTC lacked authority, writing that perpetual contracts never provide for delivery of a stock at a future date and that the CFTC's actions 'seem to represent a major disruption to the equities market.'
She still denied a temporary restraining order, finding declarations from Cboe, Citadel Securities and Healthy Markets described possible rather than likely harm.
The case has since moved to Judge Lorna Schofield, who will schedule oral argument on a preliminary injunction, with briefing on that motion closed Tuesday. The CFTC separately argues the alliance has no standing, calling it a vehicle created for the case.
Crypto Venues vs Wall Street Incumbents
The filings split the market along business lines. Coinbase Derivatives, Kalshi and Payward's Bitnomial are among platforms positioned to list the contracts, and two of them argued for the CFTC in court.
Finance Magnates reports Kalshi began offering contracts on about 50 US stocks and ETFs on November 5, and that Cboe counted roughly $375 million in 24-hour notional volume on the second day.
BigGo Finance reports Coinbase, Kalshi, Payward, DRW Holdings, Jump Trading and Paradigm filed jointly on November 9, with the court granting leave on November 10.
Opposing briefs came from Better Markets — whose legal director Dominick Freda said the CFTC was trying to 'gut 90 years of investor protections' — former SEC officials, and the American Securities Association.
What Happens Next
Finance Magnates reports the SEC has until December 31 to decide whether to overturn the exchanges' rules.
Meanwhile trading continues: Plus500 already offers Kalshi's perpetual futures to institutional clients, and CME Group — separately suing the CFTC since June over a bitcoin perpetual — plus five securities law scholars have asked to file briefs.
Platforms are operating with approval in hand and a legal question hanging over it.
Sources
- cryptobriefing.com › SEC backs CFTC in court fight over single-stock perpetual futures
- financemagnates.com › SEC Backs CFTC in Court Fight Over Perpetual Futures on US Stocks
- finance.biggo.com › SEC Backs CFTC in Perpetual Stock Futures Lawsuit, Files Brief with NY District Court
- coingape.com › SEC Backs CFTC As Coinbase, Kalshi Face Legal Fight Over US Stock Perpetuals