History Says Post-Midterm Year Brings Big Stock Gains
By @sharedot · · 6 pages
- Finance
- Stock Market
- Midterm Elections
- S P 500
Morningstar and Motley Fool data show stocks have risen every time in the 12 months after midterms, averaging 16.6% since 1950.
A Perfect Record After the Midterms
The stock market has sold off hard heading into the November 2026 midterms, rocked by a tech-led retreat in AI-related semiconductor stocks, the war in Iran, higher inflation and interest rates, and election uncertainty.
According to The Motley Fool, history offers a striking answer to the question of whether to buy the dip: since 1950, investors buying at the end of October in a midterm year have seen positive 12-month S&P 500 gains 100% of the time.
The average subsequent one-year return is 16.6%, with a median of 16.3%, ranging from a low of 3% in 2014 to a high of 33.6% in 1954. Motley Fool analyst Billy Duberstein frames the pattern as strong, though he cautions that past performance carries no guarantees.
Why Markets Rise When Elections End
The consensus explanation is uncertainty. "Markets hate uncertainty," Dan Lefkovitz, a strategist for Morningstar Indexes, told USA Today, noting that getting past an election allows markets to move on.
Morningstar's analysis of 100 years of U.S. returns found stocks have done better in November in election years than in non-election years, rising an average of 2.4% in election-year Novembers versus 0.9% otherwise.
USA Today reports the two worst election months came in 2000 and 1948, when disputed or too-close-to-call outcomes rattled markets — suggesting traders want clear winners.
Motley Fool contributing analyst Lou Whiteman added that traders shift from worrying about what might happen to reacting to what actually happened.
Unified or Divided? The Data Breaks Conventional Wisdom
Conventional Wall Street wisdom holds that divided government is better for stocks because it blocks major new policy.
But USA Today reports that Morningstar's century of data cuts against that view: stocks have averaged 1.2% monthly gains under unified federal government versus 0.7% under divided government. Other analyses point in the same seasonal direction.
USA Today cites a BlackRock finding that annual returns average 7.5% in midterm years against 12.4% in non-midterm years, and a Fidelity study showing the S&P 500 gained just 4.9% in the 12 months before midterms but 14.5% in the 12 months after, on average, since 1950.
Polls generally predict Republicans will lose control of at least one chamber.
The Risks: AI Bubble Fears and Election Chaos
Both outlets warn the pattern could break.
The Motley Fool's Reuben Gregg Brewer argues the hardest part of investing is controlling emotions, noting that an AI bubble may be inflating just as the dot-com one did — yet even the dot-com crash and Great Recession look like tiny blips a quarter-century later on long-term charts.
He recommends buying an S&P 500 tracker such as Vanguard's VOO or SPY and continuing dollar-cost averaging through any bear market.
Duberstein flags a possible AI bust or restrictions on data center construction as bigger risks than any seasonal pattern, while noting Anthropic's S-1 shows the build-out continuing. If results are disputed, USA Today says analysts advise doing nothing and staying invested.