Sorkin's 'The Social Reckoning' Flops as 'Other Mommy' Wins

Aaron Sorkin's Facebook drama opened to $5.5 million while Blumhouse's 'Other Mommy' topped the box office with $27.5 million despite poor reviews.

@sharedot

Sorkin's 'The Social Reckoning' Flops as 'Other Mommy' Wins

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • Film
  • Box Office
  • Other Mommy
  • The Social Reckoning

Aaron Sorkin's Facebook drama opened to $5.5 million while Blumhouse's 'Other Mommy' topped the box office with $27.5 million despite poor reviews.

What Happened: A Brutal Weekend for Sony

The weekend of October 9–11 delivered a lopsided result, according to Deadline and Variety. Universal's horror film 'Other Mommy,' starring Jessica Chastain in dual roles, debuted to $27.5 million from 3,365 theaters to take the domestic number one spot.

Meanwhile Sony's 'The Social Reckoning,' written and directed by Aaron Sorkin, crumbled in fifth place with a $5.5 million launch from 2,606 locations — well below the $7 million to $8 million projections Variety cites.

Why It's Surprising: Bad Reviews, Big Money

The upset is that the film nobody liked won and the prestige title nobody came out for flopped.

Variety reports 'Other Mommy' is 'one of the worst-reviewed movies of the year,' with a 19% Rotten Tomatoes score and a 'D+' CinemaScore — marks that analyst David A. Gross calls extreme even for horror, which is 'generally immune to a negative reception.'

Deadline notes the film topped expectations after $3.6 million in Thursday previews against a $19 million budget.

The Evidence: Exit Polls and Previews

The warning signs were visible from Thursday. Deadline reports 'The Social Reckoning' took just $650,000 in previews starting at 4 p.m., against $3.6 million for 'Other Mommy' from 2 p.m. previews — strong for a Blumhouse title of that size.

Per Variety, Sorkin's film played to mostly older males, a demographic that has been slow to return to theaters since the pandemic, and skewed West and East Coast: Deadline says those coasts represented 54% of the gross, with AMC Lincoln Square in New York the leading location.

'Other Mommy' played broadly, with Universal's Jim Orr telling CTV News the audience was evenly split by gender and about two-thirds aged 18 to 34.

Stakes: A $30 Million Hole for Sony

Variety reports 'The Social Reckoning' cost about $30 million to produce (half financed by Alcon, per Deadline) and added just $3.5 million from 29 international markets for a $9 million worldwide start.

Analyst David A. Gross tells Variety that stories of 'corporate intrigue, money and power have found a home on TV,' lacking the cinematic qualities that excite big-screen audiences. The outlet also suggests the 2021 whistleblower story may feel dated as AI now leads the national conversation.

Meanwhile: Cregger's Record and Digger's Disaster

Holdovers supplied their own drama. IGN India reports Zach Cregger's 'Resident Evil' overtook his 'Weapons' to become his highest-grossing film, reaching an estimated $320.2 million worldwide after a China-driven fourth weekend that added $62.65 million, $40.6 million of it from China alone.

On the flip side, Variety says Tom Cruise's 'Digger' cratered 60% in week two, limping to $14 million domestic against a reported $160 million-plus budget — projected losses of $245 million theatrically, with stars like Anne Hathaway and Guillermo del Toro defending it publicly, to no effect.

'Verity' took second at $11.5 million despite a 64% drop, per CTV News.

What Comes Next: Halloween Month and $8 Billion

Deadline pegs the overall October 9–11 marketplace at $85.157 million, down 15.6% from last weekend, but the year's big picture is strong: domestic box office crossed $8 billion on Friday, October 9 — up 19.6% year-to-date, and roughly 8% behind 2019's pace, per CTV News.

Rentrak's Paul Dergarabedian tells CTV News that 'things are definitely going to heat up in November,' with December expected to pick up at a breakneck pace.

Still ahead this month, Variety and IGN India point to 'Street Fighter,' Nathan Fielder's 'You Can See Everything' (October 16), and DC's 'Clayface' (October 23) as the titles hoping to jolt spookiest-month attendance.

Sources

  1. deadline.com › Box Office: 'Other Mommy' Leads In Opening, 'The Social Reckoning' Ghosted
  2. variety.com › Box Office: 'The Social Reckoning' Flops With $5.5 Million Debut, 'Other Mommy' Tops Box Office With $27.5 Million
  3. ctvnews.ca › 'Other Mommy' tops the box office with US$27.5M; 'The Social Reckoning' opens to $5.5M
  4. in.ign.com › Resident Evil Overtakes Weapons as Zach Cregger's Highest-Grossing Film, The Social Reckoning Bombs

More on Film