Trump-Appointed Judge Freezes Mail Ballot Rule Before Midterms

A second federal judge, this one nominated by Trump, has barred the Postal Service from implementing new mail-voting restrictions as the Supreme Court weighs the dispute.

@sharedot

Trump-Appointed Judge Freezes Mail Ballot Rule Before Midterms

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • US News
  • Mail Voting
  • Postal Service
  • Elections
  • Courts

A second federal judge, this one nominated by Trump, has barred the Postal Service from implementing new mail-voting restrictions as the Supreme Court weighs the dispute.

Second injunction lands on USPS mail-voting rule

Late Sunday, U.S. District Judge Carl J. Nichols in Washington, D.C. ordered the U.S. Postal Service not to implement the Aug. 21 rule that would limit mail balloting ahead of the November midterms.

The preliminary injunction blocks the Postal Service from enforcing regulations that stem from President Donald Trump's executive order issued earlier this year.

Nichols wrote that plaintiffs 'have demonstrated that, absent an injunction, there is an increased risk that a significant number of otherwise appropriate absentee or mail-in ballots will ultimately not be counted in the upcoming elections,' adding that 'the public has a strong interest in ensuring that doesn't happen.'

Why the ruling is a surprise

The decision is significant because Nichols was nominated by Trump himself, yet he handed the administration one of its most consequential courtroom setbacks on election rules.

In May, Nichols had refused to issue an injunction, ruling that the lawsuit seeking one was brought too early — the same reasoning the Supreme Court used late last month when it lifted an earlier freeze imposed by Judge Indira Talwani in Boston.

But once the administration issued its rule to move ahead with Trump's plan, plaintiffs in Boston and Washington, D.C. refiled their lawsuits, and Nichols concluded that it is now clear many people could lose their ability to vote if the order takes effect.

The evidence and warnings behind the hold

Election officials say it would be impossible to implement the changes this close to a general election.

The regulations would require all ballot envelope designs to be pre-approved by the Postal Service and would require states to upload the identities of those who are to receive ballots into a still-inactive online portal.

Mail ballots are already being sent out in at least three states — Alabama, North Carolina and Wisconsin — and more states are preparing to distribute mail ballots this week.

A whistleblower report to Congress warned that millions of people would be disenfranchised if the rule were allowed to take effect for the midterms, and the union representing U.S. Postal Service workers has pushed back, saying it is not the job of postal workers to verify voter eligibility.

Two judges, two appointees, one stalled rule

The legal fight now runs on parallel tracks. The Supreme Court is already considering the administration's appeal of Judge Indira Talwani's order in Boston prohibiting the Postal Service from enforcing its new mail-voting rule before the midterms.

Talwani was nominated by former President Barack Obama, while Nichols was nominated by Trump, meaning judges appointed by both parties have now frozen the rule.

Nichols' late-Sunday hold adds another obstacle to the administration's effort to rewrite election rules just as states begin mailing ballots.

The political backdrop

Mail balloting has long been a favorite target for Trump, who has falsely blamed it for his 2020 loss to Democrat Joe Biden and claimed it is a pathway to fraud despite his own use of the voting method.

The new Postal Service regulations stem from the executive order Trump issued earlier this year, and the administration had just issued its rule to move the plan forward when the plaintiffs refiled their suits.

With ballots already in motion in several states, election officials say the timing of last-minute changes is what puts voters' ballots at risk of not being counted.

What comes next for mail ballots

The immediate question is whether the Supreme Court, which lifted an earlier freeze by Talwani, will now weigh in again — this time with the administration's rule formally on the books and two district courts holding it in check.

The high court is already considering the administration's appeal of the Boston order, so the Nichols injunction arrives while that appeal is pending.

In the meantime, states continue distributing mail ballots, with more preparing to send them out this week, meaning the practical window for implementing the rule before the November midterm elections keeps narrowing.

Sources

  1. dailygazette.com › Second federal judge freezes Trump mail ballot order with US Supreme Court poised to weigh in
  2. timeslive.co.za › Second federal judge freezes Trump mail ballot order with US Supreme Court set to weigh in
  3. uk.news.yahoo.com › Second federal judge freezes Trump mail ballot order with US Supreme Court poised to weigh in

More on US News