Call of Duty Under Fire for Real Itaewon Crush Footage

Bereaved families demand Activision remove seconds-long clips of the deadly 2022 Seoul crowd crush from Modern Warfare 4's opening cinematic.

@sharedot

Call of Duty Under Fire for Real Itaewon Crush Footage

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • Gaming
  • Call Of Duty
  • Activision
  • South Korea
  • Itaewon

Bereaved families demand Activision remove seconds-long clips of the deadly 2022 Seoul crowd crush from Modern Warfare 4's opening cinematic.

What happened: real disaster footage in a war game

The game's opening cinematic, which depicts a fictional North Korean invasion of South Korea, includes seconds-long clips showing a figure performing CPR on a victim in the street, rows of bodies laid out on the road, and a victim carried away on a stretcher — actual broadcast footage from the night of October 29, 2022, when a crowd surge in a narrow Itaewon alley killed 158 people, with two more deaths later recognised as resulting from trauma from the disaster.

Korean broadcasters compared the in-game clips side by side with footage filmed that night, per The Guardian. The demand came as South Korea marked the fourth anniversary of the crush on Thursday.

Why it is surprising and painful for Korea

The 10.29 Itaewon Disaster Bereaved Families Council and a coalition of civic groups said they were appalled that scenes in which citizens performed CPR on one another and victims lay on the cold street were used 'exactly as they were' in a game, per The Independent.

Cho In Young, co-director of the Joint Action for the October 29 Itaewon Disaster, said the use of the footage showed the makers were 'insensitive to the anguish felt by the bereaved families, victims and citizens' and failed to consider the dignity of the victims, The Independent reports.

The groups said survivors and witnesses still live with trauma, and that hateful comments disparaging the Itaewon disaster were spreading online in connection with the game's premise — a fiction that casts the crush-like imagery as war casualties.

The evidence: side-by-side identifications

South Korean players identified the footage within days of launch, and broadcaster SBS compared the clips with footage from the night of the disaster, according to The Independent. One clip shows a paramedic performing CPR; another shows bodies covered by tarps, CBC News reports.

Activision told Yonhap that 'some actual news footage included in the game's opening cinematic was utilised as an element to convey the fictional story within the work,' adding that it had 'absolutely no intention of mentioning or treating lightly any actual tragic events, including the Itaewon tragedy.'

The company has not said whether it will alter or remove the footage in a future update, CBC notes, and The Guardian has contacted Activision for comment.

The stakes for a politically charged game

Modern Warfare 4 was already a political talking point in South Korea before release: The Guardian reports that conservative politicians urged president Lee Jae Myung, who is pursuing a more conciliatory approach towards North Korea, to play the game to understand what they described as the threat from Pyongyang.

The controversy now lands on a game that topped South Korea's Steam sales chart within days of release, overtaking PUBG: Battlegrounds, The Independent reports.

CBC News notes the game earned an 85 to 87 average on Metacritic and that Xbox head Asha Sharma called it 'one of the most celebrated Call of Duty games in its 24-year history,' helping the franchise reach $40 billion in lifetime revenue — so the outcry is hitting a commercial juggernaut, not a struggling title.

What comes next: signatures, apology demands

The Korea Game Users Association has called for an apology and for the footage to be replaced in an update, while cautioning, per The Independent, that the controversy 'must not be expanded into demands for censorship or unjustified restrictions on the content of the game itself.'

Cho In Young told The Independent that foreign bereaved families are visiting South Korea for the memorial service and that organisers plan to gather signatures from bereaved families and raise the issue officially.

CBC reports a national commission is continuing its investigation into the crush with a mission to 'uncover the truth of the tragedy.' Activision has not committed to any change, leaving the question of removal open as the anniversary is marked.

How to watch: the clip in question

Watch on YouTube · MrK · 1:31

  1. — North Korea has launched a full-scale invasion
  2. — Hit with some sort of sound wave
  3. — Murder of a US general inside the Pentagon

The development itself turns on video: the roughly three-second clip of a paramedic performing CPR, drawn from Getty news broadcast footage of the Itaewon crowd crush, appears in the opening cinematic of Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 4, published by Activision.

Korean broadcasters aired side-by-side comparisons of the in-game montage with the original news footage, which is how the identification spread and drove the families' joint statement demanding removal.

Watching the opening montage alongside the archival clips is the clearest way to see why the resemblance was spotted so quickly — and why families say the real disaster was repurposed, with monochrome tones and noise filters, as the aftermath of a fictional war.

Sources

  1. theguardian.com › Outcry after Call of Duty maker uses real footage of deadly Seoul crowd crush in new video game
  2. independent.co.uk › Call of Duty maker slammed for using footage of real-life crowd disaster in game
  3. cbc.ca › New Call of Duty game under fire for using footage of deadly 2022 South Korea crowd crush

More on Gaming