Supreme Court Lets Third-Country Deportations Resume
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- US News
- Immigration
- Supreme Court
The Supreme Court on Tuesday let the Trump administration resume third-country deportations without notice, setting December arguments.
What the Court Decided
The Supreme Court on Tuesday granted the Justice Department's emergency request to stay a lower-court order blocking the administration's third-country deportation policy, allowing removals to resume while litigation continues.
The brief unsigned order did not explain its reasoning, and the court's three liberal justices dissented. The court also said it will hear full oral arguments in December and issue a definitive ruling on the legality of the policy.
It is at least the second time the justices have sided with the administration at an emergency stage in this case, and the third time it has rejected efforts by U.S. District Judge Brian Murphy in Boston to pause the deportations.
Why the Ruling Matters
The decision reverses, for now, a September 18 ruling by the Boston-based 1st U.S. The appeals court had upheld Murphy's finding that deporting migrants to countries not named in their removal orders without meaningful notice violates federal immigration law and Fifth Amendment due process.
Solicitor General John Sauer told the justices the policy is an essential tool to remove certain immigrants, and the government said the lower-court order caused canceled flights and logistical problems.
Human rights groups have tallied more than 25,000 migrants deported to 29 countries under the policy, mostly to Mexico.
The Due Process Fight
The core dispute is whether migrants must get notice and a meaningful chance to raise fears of torture or persecution before being sent to a country other than their own.
The administration argues no individualized determination is needed when a receiving country has assured Secretary of State Marco Rubio it will not persecute or torture deportees.
Judge Murphy rejected that framework, and the plaintiffs' lawyer Trina Realmuto wrote that class members removed without such opportunity have faced prolonged detention, beatings, sexual assault, disappearance, and return to countries the U.S. had already granted them protection from, harms she said cannot be undone.
Where Deportees Are Sent
Under the policy, the administration has sent deportees to countries including South Sudan, Eswatini, Rwanda, Uganda, Equatorial Guinea, Liberia, and the Central African Republic, some of which the State Department warns Americans to avoid due to crime, kidnapping, or armed conflict.
The Guardian reports that earlier this month, two men expelled to Equatorial Guinea were bound, had bags fitted over their heads, were beaten, and pushed down a flight of stairs in view of other deportees, according to witnesses and human rights lawyers.
The lead plaintiff in the case, named D.V.D., is a Cuban man with severe mental illness who fears being sent somewhere without psychiatric treatment.
Warning From UN Experts
They said those at gravest risk include children, women, persons with disabilities, trafficking victims, LGBT people, human rights defenders, and stateless persons.
NBC News reports that about 15,000 people were deported to third countries in 2025, according to the Migration Policy Institute, with Mexico receiving the majority of that year's transfers.
What Comes Next
Deportations can now proceed while the Supreme Court prepares to hear the case in December. The justices asked both sides to argue whether lower courts had jurisdiction to issue nationwide relief, and whether the policy is legal or violated the due process clause and conventions against torture.
The administration, which has sought the policy as part of its broader mass-deportation agenda, says it will not remove people to countries that have not provided assurances against torture or persecution.
Sources
- npr.org › U.S. Supreme Court sides with Trump administration in third-country deportations
- cnbc.com › Supreme Court lets Trump resume third-country deportations
- sjvsun.com › Supreme Court allows Trump admin. to resume third-country deportations
- nbcnews.com › Supreme Court allows Trump's 'third country' deportation policy
- theguardian.com › US supreme court allows Trump officials to resume deportations to third countries