Missouri's Hoskins Held in Contempt Over Map Defiance
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- US News
- Missouri Redistricting
- Elections
Missouri's high court held Secretary of State Denny Hoskins in contempt for defying its map order, then cleared it Thursday after he complied.
What happened: a contempt finding, then compliance
Hours after the U.S. Supreme Court paused a federal order requiring Missouri's Trump-backed congressional map, the Missouri Supreme Court held Republican Secretary of State Denny Hoskins in contempt of its September 3 injunction barring use of that map.
Chief Justice W. Brent Powell, who had warned the state was in a "precarious situation" during a morning hearing, announced the finding in a brief afternoon session.
The court concluded Hoskins had since purged the contempt by directing local election authorities to use the 2022 congressional map, acknowledging his statement that the state court's order was now the only one in effect.
Hoskins sat silently through the morning hearing and left without answering reporters' questions.
Why it is surprising
Justice Brett Kavanaugh had rejected Hoskins' emergency bid on Tuesday, but within an hour U.S. District Judge Stephen Clark issued a temporary restraining order demanding the opposite map.
Hoskins sided with the federal order and instructed election officials to use the 2025 map in a September 8 email.
The U.S. Supreme Court's unsigned stay on Thursday — with no noted dissents, which Washington University law professor Travis Crum told St. Louis Public Radio sends "a strong signal" — left the state court's ruling standing and stranded Hoskins' position.
The evidence behind the ruling
The Missouri Supreme Court unanimously ruled September 3 that the referendum petition — backed by more than 300,000 signatures submitted in December — was "legal, sufficient, and timely," meaning the 2025 map never became law.
Hoskins nonetheless emailed election officials on September 8 instructing them to use the 2025 map, citing Clark's competing federal order.
After the Supreme Court's stay Thursday morning, Hoskins issued new guidance stating that the only governing order in effect was the Missouri Supreme Court's, and directed authorities to use the 2022 map. The state court treated that correction as purging the contempt.
Hoskins told reporters he had no regrets about his handling of the referendum.
The stakes for November
The restored 2022 map preserves a safe Kansas City seat for Democratic Rep. Emanuel Cleaver, while the Trump-backed 2025 map was drawn to help Republicans capture seven of Missouri's eight House seats.
A victory for Republicans on the map would have mattered nationally as the GOP fights to hold the House in November. Under the 2022 districts, Cleaver is heavily favored against Republican nominee Rick Brattin, according to St. Louis Public Radio.
Some voters may now cast general-election ballots in different districts than they did in the August primary, since the state will run the general election on a different map than the primary used.
Political fallout on both sides
Democrats celebrated the outcome. People Not Politicians executive director Richard von Glahn said "the law is the law, the Missouri constitution is clear as was the Missouri Supreme Court," and Cleaver praised the grassroots referendum drive as textbook community engagement.
Attorney Chuck Hatfield, representing the group, told St. Louis Public Radio the fight over using the 2025 map was "done and dusted." Republicans pressed on: Rep. Bob Onder said the case isn't over and argued it is unfair that primary voters may face different districts in November.
Attorney General Catherine Hanaway said that, as of Thursday, she saw no way the 2022 districts would not be used, while calling certainty difficult after so many twists.
What comes next
The stay from the U.S. Supreme Court remains in place through that appeal, and would persist even if the justices later agree to hear the case.
Election officials have confirmed the switch to the 2022 map is feasible, and Hoskins' office has already instructed them to proceed, leaving the referendum itself on the November ballot for voters to decide Proposition A.
Sources
- scotusblog.com › Supreme Court grants request to prevent Missouri from using congressional map expected to aid Republicans
- nbcnews.com › Supreme Court blocks Missouri's attempt to use Republican-drawn congressional map
- spectrumlocalnews.com › U.S. Supreme Court throws out Missouri congressional maps backed by Trump
- stlpr.org › U.S. Supreme Court effectively blocks Trump-backed Missouri congressional map