SEC Opens Door to Tokenized Stock Trading as Clarity Act Sits
By @sharedot · · 6 pages
- Crypto
- Regulation
- Tokenized Stocks
- SEC
- Clarity Act
Two days after the Clarity Act failed 50-49 in the Senate, the SEC created a temporary pathway for tokenized stock trading while states fight the bill.
The SEC's tokenized stock order
Just two days after the Clarity Act failed to advance in the Senate, the Securities and Exchange Commission issued an order creating a temporary pathway for trading certain tokenized stocks, inching U.S. financial markets closer to round-the-clock, 24/7 trading.
The move came under the agency's existing statutory authority rather than any new legislation, part of what CNBC describes as a rush by state and federal regulators to fill the regulatory void left by the stalled crypto market structure bill.
For crypto-native readers, the surprising part is scope: a securities regulator is now formally accommodating on-chain representations of equities, the very convergence the Clarity Act was meant to arbitrate.
CFTC files at the White House, states push back
The same day, CNBC reports the Commodity Futures Trading Commission submitted a crypto rulemaking proposal to the White House for review; the Office of Management and Budget confirmed via a public post that the rules were pending, though their details were not made public.
Meanwhile, a bipartisan coalition of state attorneys general sent a Sept. 14 letter urging the Senate Banking Committee to oppose the Clarity Act, arguing the bill displaces states' abilities to regulate securities markets and their tools to protect Americans from predatory scammers.
Brookings' Aaron Klein told CNBC capital market regulation belongs at the federal level, while Blockchain Association CEO Summer Mersinger countered that state enforcement only arrives after a crime is committed.
Why the Senate vote collapsed
Quartz reports the Senate blocked the Clarity Act from advancing with the cloture motion failing 50 to 49, far below the 60 votes needed to open floor debate.
Every Democrat voted against the measure, joined by four Republicans, with the central sticking point an ethics provision Democrats considered inadequate to prevent presidents and senior officials from profiting from crypto ventures.
That makes the regulators' speed notable: within 48 hours, the SEC and CFTC were executing what former acting CFTC chair Caroline Pham, now CEO of MoonPay Institutional, told CNBC was always a planned "plan B" at the agency level.
What comes next
The bill is not entirely dead: Senator Thom Tillis of North Carolina, who voted against it, entered a procedural motion preserving the possibility of returning the Clarity Act to the Senate floor, though Quartz notes the compressed timeline before midterm elections leaves little room to maneuver.
Coinbase CEO Brian Armstrong, a key backer of the bill, told CNBC after the failed Sept. 15 vote, "At this point, I don't think we can wait on Congress and the Senate."
Senate Banking Chairman Tim Scott called on federal agencies to set "clear rules of the road," and CNBC reports the SEC will consider modernizing custody rules for investment adviser client assets, including crypto assets.