Moon May Have Formed in Just 5 Hours After Theia Impact
By @sharedot · · 7 pages
- Science
- Space
- Astronomy
- Moon Formation
New simulations suggest the Moon could have assembled in as little as five hours after the Theia impact.
A shockingly fast birth for the Moon
New simulations led by Adeene Denton of the Southwest Research Institute indicate the Moon may have formed in just five hours after the giant impact between the early Earth and Theia, a Mars-size protoplanet.
The published findings — reported by Space and RBC-Ukraine, citing The Astrophysical Journal Letters — build on the leading giant-impact hypothesis refined for years by planetary scientist Robin Canup. In the fast scenario, an intact Moon emerged from the debris ring within hours of the collision.
Why temperature changes everything
The surprise is that prior models largely ignored the geology of the colliding worlds.
'Models have evolved to include material strength, something that's really important when you're studying collisions between smaller bodies like asteroids or for my previous paper about the formation of the Pluto–Charon system,' Denton said in a statement.
Warmer bodies are weaker, so a young, still-hot Theia absorbed the collision differently, affecting how debris was strewn around Earth. 'We weren't sure it would matter for the moon or not.
When we did the simulations, we found it actually matters quite a bit,' Denton said.
Two scenarios from one impact
According to the simulations, timing and temperature split the outcomes. If a colder Theia struck Earth roughly 100 to 150 million years after the planets formed, the debris ring would have let the Moon accrete gradually, and more of Theia would have survived to merge with Earth.
A hotter Theia striking less than 60 million years after formation could be utterly obliterated, producing a massive debris disk. Space reports that when Denton used equal temperature structures for both bodies, 'within around five hours, an intact moon emerged.'
Composition puzzles and exomoon stakes
In both scenarios the Moon appears made mostly of Theia's mantle with little Earth mantle mixed in — puzzling, given the Moon's similarity to Earth's mantle and unexplained isotope differences.
Robin Canup, not involved in the study, said the results 'imply a potential connection between the physical properties of the moon today, including perhaps its volatile content, and the thermal state of the Earth and Theia,' which might help constrain when the impact occurred.
Space notes the fast-formation scenario could also make searching for moon-forming disks around rocky exoplanets fruitless, since such disks would be short-lived.
What comes next
The results, published Sept. RBC-Ukraine notes the flexible new scenario helps resolve anomalies in the Moon's physical and chemical properties that the traditional slow-disk view struggles to explain.
Future work will likely test how different thermal states and impact timings reshape the debris disk, with the goal of pinning down when Theia actually struck and whether the Moon truly was born in a single five-hour burst.