Clarkson Escalates Feud: 'You're a Liar,' Store Fires Back

Kelly Clarkson calls Art of Play liars over a $15,000 bird automaton; the store insists she left after five minutes.

@sharedot

Clarkson Escalates Feud: 'You're a Liar,' Store Fires Back

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • Celebrity
  • Kelly Clarkson
  • Art Of Play
  • Social Media Feuds

Kelly Clarkson calls Art of Play liars over a $15,000 bird automaton; the store insists she left after five minutes.

What Happened: A Bird Automaton and a Thumbs-Down

The drama began when Clarkson posted on X on Saturday, October 10, that she 'drove all the way to Brooklyn' to Art of Play, 'had a few things in mind to buy,' and 'was literally looked at as if I couldn't afford it,' signing off with a thumbs-down emoji and a comparison to the 'Pretty Woman' scene where Julia Roberts' Vivian Ward is snubbed on Rodeo Drive, as Page Six and Us Weekly both report.

The Hollywood Reporter says the shop sells puzzles, games, toys and books and features a 26-seat theater for magic performances.

Why It's Surprising: A Star With 9 Million Followers Versus a Mom-and-Pop

What makes this feud remarkable is the asymmetry. Page Six notes Clarkson, 44, is a Grammy winner and 'American Idol' alum known for her easygoing persona, and a source told Page Six she must have been 'livid' because public callouts are 'just not who she is.'

Yahoo's commentary went further, arguing the episode is 'both a waste and abuse of power,' noting Clarkson has roughly 9 million followers on X while the store is run by twin magicians Dan Buck and Dave Buck and children's book author Adam Rubin.

The post drew more than a quarter-million likes, per Yahoo.

The Evidence: A Price Tag Photo and Molly the Bird

The fight's central evidence is Molly, a one-of-a-kind singing and dancing bird automaton that the store calls a 'de facto mascot' and says is permanently attached to the wall.

Clarkson doubled down with a photo that Page Six says appeared to show a $15,000 price tag next to the bird titled 'Singing Bird,' though the outlet reports the image was too pixelated to independently verify the price.

SheKnows adds that Molly appears in a pinned September Instagram post next to the words 'Our favorite items not for sale.'

The Store's Rebuttal: Five Minutes and a $2,000 Alternative

In a second statement, Art of Play says Clarkson spent only five minutes in the store and was told a nearly identical automaton by Seattle artist Bliss Kolb could be purchased for $15,000, and that a different singing bird made by a traditional German clockmaking shop, costing about $2,000, could have been taken home that day.

'She did not stick around long enough to see it,' the store said, according to The Hollywood Reporter and Us Weekly. The store also quoted Clarkson's own hit back at her: 'what doesn't kill you makes you stronger.'

Video: The Feud Hits the Celebrity Buzz Roundup

ABC News folded the story into its celebrity buzz roundup alongside Tobey Maguire officiating his ex-wife's wedding and Kelly Osbourne opening up about seeking help after her father's death, a sign the automaton spat had graduated into the day's mainstream pop-culture conversation.

USA Today, meanwhile, explains why audiences can't look away: experts say celebrities' reviews fuel social comparison and schadenfreude, and Clarkson's 'Texan charm and relatable story' give fans a 'deeply parasocial connection' that makes them trust her account more than they might another star's.

What Comes Next: An Off-Ramp Built Around a Bird

Business Insider cites PR expert Evan Nierman, CEO of Red Banyan, who says the feud 'is more about feelings than facts' and that Clarkson made the mistake of playing the victim in a contest of narratives she has little to gain from.

His suggested off-ramp: get her back to the store and find a way to get her a singing bird. The store says it has reached out to Clarkson directly and hopes 'someday we can all laugh about this misunderstanding,' per The Hollywood Reporter — but neither side, nor Molly, has sung yet.

Sources

  1. pagesix.com › Inside Kelly Clarkson’s ‘Pretty Woman’-style feud with small Brooklyn business
  2. usmagazine.com › Kelly Clarkson’s Public Feud With Brooklyn Store Art of Play Explained
  3. hollywoodreporter.com › New York Store Says Kelly Clarkson Spent “5 Minutes” Inside
  4. yahoo.com › Kelly Clarkson’s Brooklyn magic shop feud was a viral sensation — and a teachable moment
  5. sheknows.com › Here's The $15,000 Bird Kelly Clarkson Is Arguing With A Brooklyn Store About
  6. abcnews.com › Kelly Clarkson’s store feud, Tobey Maguire’s wedding surprise and more celebrity buzz
  7. usatoday.com › Kelly Clarkson, a local business and the return of social media beef
  8. businessinsider.com › A PR pro says Kelly Clarkson made one big mistake in her feud with a Brooklyn toy shop

More on Celebrity