Wild Lemurs Sing Like Opera Sopranos, Researchers Report
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- Singing
- Opera
- Vocal Technique
- Indri Lemur
Researchers at Warwick and Turin say the indri lemur, the world's only singing lemur, uses the same formant-tuning technique as trained opera singers.
What the Researchers Say Happened
Scientists from the University of Warwick, the University of Turin and Madagascar report that the indri lemur of Madagascar — the world's only known singing lemur — opens its mouth wider on higher notes, just as a trained soprano does.
According to the BBC, co-author Dr Chiara De Gregorio called it "the kind of fine-tuned coordination between voice and body that we usually associate with trained human singers, not with a lemur singing from the forest canopy."
The study, which Popular Science notes was published in the journal PLOS Computational Biology, is described as the first direct evidence of this vocal-tract coordination in a non-human primate.
Why It Surprises Vocal Specialists
Formant tuning is a technique human singers train for years to master: as pitch rises, a singer widens the mouth so harmonics align with the resonant frequencies of the vocal tract, amplifying the voice.
Popular Science explains that indris appear to do this instinctively, opening their mouths wider frame by frame as their songs climb in pitch.
Co-author Filippo Carugati, quoted by Good Morning America, said "the same phenomenon we hear in an opera house, when a trained singer opens their mouth wider to project a high note, appears to be happening in a lemur whose lineage split from ours something like 70 million years ago."
The Evidence Behind the Claim
The team analyzed 83 video recordings of 19 wild indris, combining field audio with markerless motion-tracking technology that followed upper and lower lip positions frame by frame, according to Popular Science.
Researchers found a consistent pattern, with no significant differences between male and female songs — Carugati told Good Morning America it "looks like a species-level feature rather than an idiosyncrasy of one or two animals."
He also cautioned that the researchers cannot prove the animals do this "on purpose," only that the physical result matches the acoustic strategy of trained singers.
What the Lemurs Get Out of It
Indris rely on long-distance songs to hold territory in dense rainforest and to strengthen bonds within their social group, and Good Morning America reports Carugati's argument that "anything that increases how far and how clearly that signal carries has a real, plausible benefit."
Because the songs act as warnings to rival groups through thick forest, the difference between a song that carries and one that does not can be decisive. The BBC reports researchers believe the lemurs use formant tuning for a similar purpose as professionals: to make their songs carry further.
Convergent Evolution, 74 Million Years Apart
Humans and indris last shared a common ancestor roughly 74 million years ago, and both the BBC and Popular Science report that the scientists believe the sound-projection technique developed independently in the two lineages.
Carugati, quoted by Good Morning America, described convergent evolution as when unrelated species independently evolve a similar trait because they face the same problem — here, sending an acoustic signal over a long distance.
He noted the team has not yet found a genetic or mechanistic explanation for the convergence, leaving a major open question for future work.
What Comes Next for Indri Research
The Warwick and Turin teams' earlier work, as the BBC recounts, suggested the indri could illuminate how humans evolved to make music, and a 2025 study they produced found young lemurs learn to sing in a manner similar to human children.
With the formant-tuning evidence now in PLOS Computational Biology, the researchers are left probing why the mechanism exists and how widespread it is across wild populations.
Carugati acknowledged to Good Morning America that data varied between subjects because only video frames showing the relevant facial landmarks could be used — a constraint future filming could ease.