Hoskins Backs Down, Orders Missouri to Use 2022 Map
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- US News
- Missouri
- Redistricting
- Supreme Court
- Midterms
After the Supreme Court's stay, Secretary of State Denny Hoskins directed local election authorities to use the 2022 congressional map for November.
What Happened
Missouri Secretary of State Denny Hoskins issued new guidance on Thursday directing local election authorities to use the state's 2022 congressional map for the November midterms, following the U.S. Supreme Court's stay of a federal judge's order that had required the Trump-backed 2025 map.
In a statement, Hoskins said that after the high court's action, "the only governing order in effect is from the Missouri Supreme Court," which had ruled the 2025 map was never law.
Why the Reversal Is Surprising
Only a day earlier, Hoskins had defied the Missouri Supreme Court by telling election authorities to use the new Trump-backed map, citing a federal temporary restraining order from Chief U.S. District Judge Stephen Clark.
According to SCOTUSblog, Clark issued that order less than an hour after Justice Brett Kavanaugh declined to disturb the state court's ruling, creating a direct conflict between state and federal directives.
The Supreme Court resolved it Thursday morning with a brief, unsigned order pausing Clark's ruling, with no public dissents from any justice — a signal Washington University law professor Travis Crum, quoted by St. Louis Public Radio, said suggested the 2022 map would govern.
The Evidence: A Court Timeline
In December, opponents submitted more than 300,000 signatures for a referendum on the 2025 map, which Hoskins rejected on August 4, the day of the primary. On September 3, the Missouri Supreme Court unanimously ruled the referendum valid and the new map suspended.
Kavanaugh rejected Hoskins' emergency request Tuesday; Clark then issued his restraining order.
The 8th Circuit declined a stay Wednesday, and Thursday the full Supreme Court granted the stay request from People Not Politicians — SCOTUSblog reports the order came just nine days before the deadline to send military and overseas ballots.
The Contempt Ruling
The compliance pivot followed direct pressure from the state's highest court.
The Missouri Supreme Court held a hearing Thursday on whether to hold Hoskins in contempt for his September 8 email instructing officials to use the 2025 map, where Chief Justice W. Brent Powell said, "We're in a precarious situation."
According to SCOTUSblog, the court found Hoskins in contempt at a 3 p.m. hearing but indicated he had corrected it by directing local authorities to the 2022 map.
Hoskins, who sat silently during the morning session and left without answering reporters, later said he had no regrets about how he handled the redistricting push, per St. Louis Public Radio.
What's at Stake
The 2025 map, drawn at President Trump's urging after Missouri became the second Republican-led state after Texas to redraw districts, was designed to dismantle the Kansas City seat of Democratic Rep. Emanuel Cleaver and help Republicans win seven of the state's eight House seats.
Restoring the 2022 map preserves Cleaver's safe seat, a significant blow to GOP efforts to pad their House majority in the midterms.
St. Louis Public Radio reports Democrats celebrated; Cleaver praised the referendum organizers, saying voters "did what one can do only in a democracy, and they went out and organized." The referendum itself, Proposition A, remains on the November ballot.
What Comes Next
Legal uncertainty has not fully lifted. The 8th Circuit has scheduled a September 17 hearing in the case brought by Rep. Robert Onder and state Sen. Rick Brattin, who won their primaries under the 2025 map and argue voters should not face changed districts between the primary and general election.
Onder told reporters the case isn't over, while Republican Attorney General Catherine Hanaway said that, as of Thursday, she saw no way the 2022 districts wouldn't be used, though she cautioned "there have been so many twists and turns here."
Because Missouri ran its August primary on the 2025 map, some voters may not be able to vote for the same candidate they chose earlier.
Sources
- spectrumlocalnews.com › U.S. Supreme Court throws out Missouri congressional maps backed by Trump
- scotusblog.com › Supreme Court grants request to prevent Missouri from using congressional map expected to aid Republicans
- stlpr.org › U.S. Supreme Court effectively blocks Trump-backed Missouri congressional map
- scrippsnews.com › Supreme Court rejects Trump-backed Missouri congressional maps