Heirs Seek to Halt Sotheby's $180M Van Gogh Sale
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- Art
- Auctions
- Restitution
- Van Gogh
- Sothebys
Fischer heirs claim Van Gogh's Blossoming Chestnut Trees was sold under Nazi-era duress in 1936, days before Sotheby's auctions it.
A Record Bid Threatened Five Days Before the Hammer
A last-minute restitution claim has thrown Wednesday's Sotheby's auction of Vincent van Gogh's *Châtaigniers en fleurs* (1890), also known as *Blossoming Chestnut Trees*, into doubt.
According to ARTnews, the heirs of Samuel Fischer — a Jewish publisher whose family fled Nazi Germany — asked the house to withdraw the painting from its November 18 sale, where it carries an unofficial estimate of around $180 million that would shatter the artist's $117.2 million auction record set at Christie's in 2022.
Sotheby's says it is still scheduled to offer the painting.
The Heirs' Claim: A Family Forced to Sell
The Fischer heirs say the family was forced to sell the painting in 1936 because of financial pressure brought on by Nazi persecution.
Their lawyer, Gunnar Schnabel, challenged Sotheby's to prove that the family received fair market value — and that the family would have sold the picture even if the Nazis had never come to power. "Otherwise," he wrote in an email seen by The New York Times, "no auction may take place."
The heirs say the family fled Berlin for Vienna in 1936, and the painting sold months later after the publishing house suffered heavy losses under Nazi rule.
Sotheby's Evidence: A Voluntary 1936 Sale
Sotheby's is pushing back, telling ARTnews that the archives of dealer Paul Cassirer confirm the painting sold for 68,000 Swiss francs — about $22,000 — in June 1936, which the house considers a strong price for a Van Gogh at the time.
The house notes the Netherlands was outside Nazi control, and that the work remained on consignment for nearly three years before selling.
Sotheby's lawyer Luke Nikas told ARTnews the painting went to an independent buyer at fair market value, and that a postwar brochure by Gottfried Bermann Fischer listing paintings the family wanted to recover does not include the Van Gogh.
As ARTnews notes by comparison, another Van Gogh that sold for $15,000 at Parke-Bernet in 1935 fetched $117.2 million at Christie's in 2022.
What Counts as Duress Under New York Law
The legal question, as ARTnews explains, is whether a painting sold outside Nazi Germany, to an independent buyer, at a good price can still be a forced sale. Nikas points to two Picasso cases: in *Zuckerman v.
Metropolitan Museum of Art*, a 2018 ruling found a 1938 sale did not meet the standard for duress, and in *Bennigson v. Solomon R. Guggenheim Foundation*, a New York judge ruled in 2024 that economic pressure from Nazi persecution was not enough when the buyer had not contributed to it.
Meanwhile, ARTnews reports Congress amended the HEAR Act in April to eliminate the laches defense, which lawyer Judd Grossman says has swung the pendulum "dramatically in favor of claimants" — though it does not change the test for duress itself.
The Cézannes and the Timing Problem
Two companion Cézannes complicate the picture.
ARTnews reports one now hangs at the Harvard Art Museums without any claim from the Fischer heirs, and Gisela Bermann Fischer told Christie's in 2007 she would not oppose selling the other — while reserving the right, in confidential correspondence Sotheby's says it never saw, to challenge sales of other family paintings.
The timing is also contested: ARTnews reports Sotheby's first heard from the heirs' representatives on November 12, five days before the auction, after the sale had been publicized since early October.
Ynetnews adds a further wrinkle, noting that late patriarch Carlos Pedro Blaquier faced, but was never convicted of, charges linked to detentions under Argentina's military dictatorship.
Dialogue Before Wednesday — Or a Withdrawn Lot
The heirs' lawyer said his client is prepared to work toward a fair and just solution under the Washington Principles, the international guidelines for handling Nazi-era claims that dutchnews.nl notes are not legally binding.
Sotheby's told The New York Times its research has not established the painting was sold under duress but that it is committed to a mutually satisfactory resolution.
The Blaquier family, per ARTnews, says it welcomes constructive dialogue with the Fischer heirs while noting the information to date has not established duress.