SEC and CFTC Write Crypto Rules With CLARITY Act Dead

After the CLARITY Act failed 49-50 in the Senate, the SEC and CFTC issued at least nine regulatory moves to govern crypto without Congress.

@sharedot

SEC and CFTC Write Crypto Rules With CLARITY Act Dead

By @sharedot · · 7 pages

  • Crypto
  • Regulation
  • SEC
  • Cftc
  • Clarity Act

After the CLARITY Act failed 49-50 in the Senate, the SEC and CFTC issued at least nine regulatory moves to govern crypto without Congress.

What happened: a bill dies, rulemaking accelerates

The CLARITY Act is dead for 2026 after the Senate failed cloture 49-50 on September 15, falling 11 votes short of the 60 needed. But U.S. crypto regulation did not stall.

Within 24 hours, SEC Chair Paul Atkins confirmed the crypto agenda would proceed, and CFTC Chair Michael Selig echoed him, calling the moment "go time" for the agencies to act within the remaining two years of the administration's term.

CoinGape counts at least nine concrete regulatory moves by the two agencies since the vote, made entirely under existing statutory authority rather than new legislation.

Why it is surprising: the Innovation Exemption

The most consequential move came on September 17, when the SEC issued its long-awaited "Innovation Exemption."

Elliptic reports the order grants Tokenized Securities Venues five years of conditional relief from securities laws to trade tokenized U.S. stocks on-chain via permissioned AMM liquidity pools — the first time certain participants can trade tokenized U.S.-listed stocks through DeFi protocols without registering as exchanges or broker-dealers.

Conditions include issuer notification, auditable smart contracts on public ledgers, anti-manipulation rules, and OFAC sanctions compliance.

The same day, the CFTC issued a no-action letter saying passive software providers, including self-hosted wallet developers, need not register as introducing brokers.

The evidence: nine moves in two weeks

According to CoinGape, the agencies' moves include a joint token taxonomy from March classifying BTC, ETH, XRP, SOL and DOGE as digital commodities, a harmonization MOU ending jurisdictional overlap, and a CFTC Innovation Advisory Committee with Coinbase, Ripple and Robinhood CEOs at the table.

On September 24, the CFTC issued FAQs telling registered firms how they can hold customer funds in tokenized investments and use public blockchains for recordkeeping, per Elliptic.

The stakes: markets and a thinning bench

Markets felt the CLARITY failure immediately: CoinGape reports spot Bitcoin ETFs shed $450 million in the biggest single-day outflow since June, with Fidelity's FBTC down $214.8 million, BlackRock's IBIT down $161.7 million, and Ether ETFs losing $141.47 million.

Meanwhile, the regulatory bench is thinning.

According to TradingView, Commissioner Hester Peirce — the industry's "Crypto Mom" — leaves the SEC on October 2, leaving Chair Atkins and Mark Uyeda as the only two commissioners, while the CFTC has been run by Chair Selig as sole commissioner since December 2025.

What comes next: agency rules, repeal risk

There are limits to what agencies can do without Congress.

CoinGape notes rules written without a statute can be reversed by a future commission, the Innovation Exemption is temporary and volume-capped, and the CFTC's proposed rule — "Regulation Crypto Asset Transactions and Regulation Crypto Asset Markets" — is still under White House OIRA review.

Senator Cynthia Lummis warned that if the CLARITY Act misses this Congress, market structure legislation could slip to 2030, and midterm math makes a 2026 revival effectively zero.

Elliptic notes Democrats are already raising concerns about leadership vacancies at both agencies, which could complicate any future legislative effort if they take the Senate in November.

Sources

  1. coingape.com › It's Over for Waiting on Congress: SEC and CFTC Make 9 Moves to Write Crypto Rules Without the CLARITY Act
  2. elliptic.co › Crypto regulatory affairs: SEC and CFTC push cryptoasset rulemaking in wake of failed CLARITY vote
  3. tradingview.com › Crypto regulation at SEC, CFTC to come down to 3 commissioners following key resignation

More on Crypto