Webb Finds Interstellar Comet 3I/ATLAS Rich in Heavy Methane
By @sharedot · · 6 pages
- Science
- Space
- Astronomy
- Interstellar Comet
Two new Webb studies find interstellar comet 3I/ATLAS carries a deuterium-to-hydrogen ratio far above any Solar System body and may predate the Sun.
A comet older than the Solar System
Interstellar comet 3I/ATLAS, the third known visitor from beyond our Solar System, discovered on July 1, 2025, is yielding extraordinary chemical secrets.
According to ScienceAlert, a NASA Solar System Exploration Division team used the James Webb Space Telescope in late December 2025, when the comet was about 2.5 times Earth's distance from the Sun, to analyze the atmosphere, or coma, puffing off its ices.
The team measured the deuterium-to-hydrogen ratio in methane and found the comet holds significantly more heavy methane than any body in the Solar System — 13 times more than comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko, per ScienceAlert.
The researchers say the elevated ratio is consistent with ices forming in a cold, low-metallicity interstellar or protostellar environment under high cosmic ray irradiation.
Why the findings are so surprising
The chemistry suggests 3I/ATLAS may be far older than our own star.
ScienceAlert reports that the comet's low carbon-13 content hints it formed in an ancient Universe not yet enriched by heavy elements from supernova explosions, meaning it could have formed more than 7 billion years before the Sun ignited and drifted for eons before crossing our path.
The researchers suggest its ices may have formed in a prestellar core — a super-cold region around -263°C (-440°F) where gases freeze onto dust grains, favoring heavier deuterium.
Separately, ScienceAlert notes the comet may even predate many of the atoms that make up our own Sun and planets, which were forged later in dying massive stars. That makes it a pristine sample from the hidden depths of an ancient cosmic nursery.
Dusty ice grains link to distant worlds
A Southwest Research Institute-led study, reported by phys.org, examined ice grains streaming from 3I/ATLAS with Webb's Near-Infrared Spectrograph three times between August 2025 and April 2026, before and after closest approach to the Sun.
The grains are tiny aggregates of water ice and dust about a micron or smaller, and their spectral fingerprints differ from most Solar System comets: the strong 3-micron water-ice band is present, but the weaker 1.5- and 2.0-micron bands are missing or faint.
phys.org reports the team's models point to unusually dusty ice — and that the band shape resembles spectra of some icy trans-Neptunian objects beyond Neptune.
Per phys.org, lead author Silvia Protopapa says the finding suggests the icy building blocks of planets around other stars may share a common range of physical properties with our own.
What comes next for the visitor
Both papers are published in peer-reviewed journals — the methane study in Nature Astronomy and the ice-grain study in The Astrophysical Journal Letters — and both leave open questions.
phys.org notes that the grain properties in the coma appeared to change over time by the final April 2026 observation, favoring a population of larger, ice-rich grains, and the team cannot yet tell whether that reflects solar heating or new material exposed as the comet's surface eroded.
Per phys.org, co-author Michael Kelley of the University of Maryland says telling those possibilities apart is a key open question.
Future Webb observations of comets in our Solar System and newly discovered interstellar visitors will test whether 3I/ATLAS is typical or an outlier among alien planetesimals.