First 'Phoenix Planet' Rises From a Dead Star's Ashes

Astronomers report the first candidate second-generation planet, a Jupiter-like world orbiting the white dwarf HS 0209+0832, born from stellar debris.

@sharedot

First 'Phoenix Planet' Rises From a Dead Star's Ashes

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • Science
  • Astronomy
  • Exoplanets
  • White Dwarfs

Astronomers report the first candidate second-generation planet, a Jupiter-like world orbiting the white dwarf HS 0209+0832, born from stellar debris.

A planet born from a dying star

Astronomers led by the University of Warwick report what may be the first known second-generation planet — a Jupiter-like world that appears to have formed from material expelled as a dying star ended its life.

The planet orbits HS 0209+0832, a white dwarf roughly 270 light-years away in the constellation Cetus, and circles it every 4.4 days. The team reanalyzed 25-year-old Hubble data and combined it with NASA's TESS and the retired FUSE ultraviolet telescope, publishing the result in Nature Astronomy.

Lead author Jamie Williams called it the first example of a planet forming around a white dwarf.

Why this breaks the usual script

Planets like Earth form from the disk of material surrounding a newborn star, and conventional thinking held that a white dwarf stage was an epilogue to any planetary system.

When a sun-like star dies it swells into a red giant and swallows its inner planets, which is what is expected to happen to Mercury, Venus and Earth. Mashable notes that until now, planets linked to stellar remnants had only been tied to pulsars, a rarer type of collapsed star.

Williams framed the finding as the familiar planetary system being only the first chapter of a potentially longer tale, with new characters showing up.

The niobium smoking gun

The key evidence is chemical. Hubble's archived spectrum of HS 0209+0832 revealed niobium at levels more than 1000 times that of our Sun, alongside carbon, nickel, copper and zinc, with almost no silicon or iron — a mix matching nothing in our solar system, not even Halley's comet.

Co-author Nicholas Stone, a theoretical astrophysicist at the University of Wisconsin–Madison, said heavy elements like niobium are not made by fusion in stellar cores but only in the exotic conditions inside dying stars, calling niobium 'a signpost of these death throes.'

Boris Gaensicke recalled his astonishment at finding niobium in a white dwarf for the first time.

A close-in giant being stripped alive

TESS monitored HS 0209+0832 for four months and found recurring brightness changes repeating every 4.4 days, suggesting the candidate planet orbits only a few million kilometers from the white dwarf.

According to Universe Today, the orbit spans just 4.4 days at about 2.7 million km, while SSBCrack News reports the signal implies a distance of roughly 3.7 million miles — closer than Mercury sits to the Sun.

The planet appears to be a gas giant slightly more massive than Jupiter, and the young, blazingly hot white dwarf's ultraviolet radiation is evaporating its outer atmosphere, with some material falling back onto the star.

Habitable zones after stellar death

The finding raises the possibility that second-generation planets could one day support life.

Williams told Universe Today that as a white dwarf cools it holds a steady temperature for tens of billions of years, so a close-in rocky planet — averaging around 2.7 million km from the star — could remain in the habitable zone far longer than Earth has.

Mashable adds that because white dwarfs are about Earth-sized, a transiting planet's atmosphere is much easier to study, and a companion commentary suggests the James Webb Space Telescope could detect water, carbon dioxide and possible biosignatures in just a few passes.

Williams noted such worlds might struggle to start life, however, because they likely would not receive the same molecules as Earth.

What comes next

The planet remains a candidate: no observatory has seen it directly, and confirmation will need further study.

Williams told Universe Today that niobium can now serve as a signature of accretion from second-generation planets, so observing more hot white dwarfs with Hubble could find more candidates, though there are not yet enough statistics to predict how common they are.

Since more than 95% of Milky Way stars become white dwarfs, Williams told Reuters, via Kuwait Times, that second-generation planets around them could be far more common than around pulsars. Our own Sun will eventually follow the same path.

A companion Nature Astronomy study also described a red dwarf siphoning material from a brown dwarf in an 87-minute orbit.

Sources

  1. universetoday.com › Astronomers Detect Potential 'Second Generation' Planet Around Dying Stellar White Dwarf
  2. open.kg › For the first time, evidence of a second-generation planet around a dead star
  3. mashable.com › Astronomers spot signs of a planet born from a dying star's remains
  4. news.ssbcrack.com › Hubble Reveals Clue to Second-Generation Planet Around White Dwarf
  5. kuwaittimes.com › Alien 'phoenix planet' was born from the ashes of a dying star

More on Science