Critics Call 'Clayface' a Surprising, Messy DC Body-Horror Bet

Early reviews praise Tom Rhys Harries in James Watkins' gory standalone 'Clayface,' a divisive DCU bet opening October 23.

@sharedot

Critics Call 'Clayface' a Surprising, Messy DC Body-Horror Bet

By @sharedot · · 6 pages

  • Film
  • Clayface
  • Dc Universe
  • Body Horror
  • Movie Reviews

Early reviews praise Tom Rhys Harries in James Watkins' gory standalone 'Clayface,' a divisive DCU bet opening October 23.

What Critics Are Saying About the DCU's First Trip Into Body Horror

The first reviews of James Watkins' 'Clayface' are online ahead of its October 23 theatrical release, and Rotten Tomatoes' review roundup says critics see the third DC Universe movie as a welcome change of texture even when it doesn't always deliver.

USA Today gives the R-rated film two stars, calling it an unnerving, frustrating thriller that immerses the obscure Batman villain in Cronenbergian body horror and amounts to a sort of superhero version of 'The Substance'.

Reviewers quoted by Rotten Tomatoes invoke 'The Fly', 'Darkman' and 'Malignant' as touchstones, with The Hollywood Reporter's Frank Scheck comparing its psychological depth to body-horror maestros like David Cronenberg and Sam Raimi.

Why Tom Rhys Harries Is the Reviewers' Consensus

Across both outlets, the loudest praise lands on star Tom Rhys Harries, who plays movie star Matt Hagen, an actor disfigured by a Gotham mob boss and transformed by experimental nanocells into a malleable, shape-shifting mass.

Rotten Tomatoes' roundup quotes comicbookmovie.com calling him 'a brilliant find by DC Studios', while IndieWire says he conveys genuine pathos under gobs of makeup and VFX, and Daily Dead hopes the protagonist-worth-caring-about returns.

USA Today credits Harries with a complicated human touch boosted by excellent effects work, even as it argues the Mike Flanagan and Hossein Amini screenplay gives everyone — Hagen included — little character development beyond mediocre archetypes.

USA Today also singles out the gore as the film's strength, from a icky airplane-bathroom eye scene to gleeful 'Malignant'-style nightclub mayhem.

Where Reviewers Say It Stumbles

The enthusiasm is decidedly mixed. Josh Wilding of comicbookmovie.com, quoted in the Rotten Tomatoes roundup, argues the film is 'too tame to be a classic horror movie and too bland to be a great DC Comics adaptation', and notes the 'classic Clayface' payoff lasts only 10 or 15 seconds.

Brian Tallerico of rogerebert.com complains the movie never looks like it takes place anywhere but a backlot, and USA Today adds its own complaint: Gotham, usually a character in itself, is rendered here as a pedestrian place with almost no personality — a bad look, in the reviewer's view, for the new DCU's first trip to the iconic locale.

Flickering Myth, via Rotten Tomatoes, calls the mind-bender ending unearned, and Fresh Fiction says women are depicted abysmally.

The Stakes for Horror in James Gunn's DCU

For film watchers, the real question is whether this small-scale, deliberately uncommercial experiment signals a direction.

Rotten Tomatoes' roundup quotes Variety's Guy Lodge — who calls the film one that exceeds expectations while staying at its 'spiritual B-movie station' — arguing the DCU 'could use more movies like this one'.

Daily Dead's Matt Donato, also quoted there, praises an 'uncharacteristically vile' brand of DC storytelling under James Gunn's watch, while Amelia Emberwing of Pickety Wing-style outlets hails its refusal to chase broad appeal as its greatest triumph.

USA Today notes the film, like 'Supergirl', stands apart as standalone rather than world-building, and skeptically asks why a decent villain actor wasn't given a bigger stage.

Sources

  1. editorial.rottentomatoes.com › Clayface First Reviews: Tom Rhys Harries Shines in a Messy but Distinctive DC Horror Story
  2. usatoday.com › 'Clayface' at least gets the gore right in messy DC miss – Review

More on Film