Buster Posey Headlines 14 Newcomers on Hall of Fame Ballot

Buster Posey leads 14 first-time candidates on the 2027 Baseball Hall of Fame ballot, with results due January 19 and enshrinement in July.

@sharedot

Buster Posey Headlines 14 Newcomers on Hall of Fame Ballot

By @sharedot · · 7 pages

  • Sports
  • Baseball
  • Mlb Hall Of Fame
  • Buster Posey
  • San Francisco Giants

Buster Posey leads 14 first-time candidates on the 2027 Baseball Hall of Fame ballot, with results due January 19 and enshrinement in July.

Posey tops a rookie-laden Cooperstown ballot

The National Baseball Hall of Fame has unveiled its 2027 ballot, and former San Francisco Giants catcher Buster Posey headlines 14 newcomers joining 13 holdovers, according to The New York Times.

Posey, now the Giants' president of baseball operations, won the 2012 NL MVP and three World Series titles (2010, 2012, 2014) before retiring at 34 after a resurgent 2021 season in which his .889 OPS helped San Francisco to a franchise-record 107 wins.

Other first-timers include left-hander Jon Lester, who won World Series titles with Boston and the Cubs, and Yankees outfielder Brett Gardner. Yahoo Sports notes Posey hit .302/.372/.460 with a 129 wRC+ and 45 bWAR in his career, and its JAWS measure puts his 40.8 score 14th among catchers all-time.

Why a first-ballot nod is not guaranteed

Voters must weigh Posey's peak against his short career: he retired with exactly 1,500 hits, which The New York Times reports would be the fewest by a Hall of Fame position player elected by the writers since Ralph Kiner (1,451) in 1975.

The Times also notes he would be the first writer-elected player with fewer than 6,000 plate appearances since Jackie Robinson in 1962.

His peak case is striking — Posey caught 13 postseason shutouts, the most by a catcher in MLB history, and 23.2 percent of his 56 postseason starts were shutout wins, per The New York Times.

Yahoo Sports adds that Posey's 36.5 peak bWAR tops the 34.9 average of the 17 catchers already enshrined, though his 45 career bWAR trails their 53.7 average.

Returnees climbing toward the 75 percent bar

Chase Utley is the top returning candidate after jumping from 39.8 percent in 2025 to 59.1 percent last cycle, needing another similar surge to reach the 75 percent threshold.

Yahoo Sports reports much of that gain came from first-time and returning non-2025 voters, who named Utley on 42 of 51 ballots (82.4 percent).

Andy Pettitte, on the ballot for a ninth year, reached 48.5 percent, while Félix Hernández more than doubled his support to 46.1 percent and Alex Rodríguez drew 40 percent, per Yahoo Sports.

The New York Times reports Omar Vizquel went the other way, falling to 18.4 percent in his 10th and final year after abuse allegations. If Posey or Utley break through, the Times suggests it could crack the door for other peak-driven cases.

Stakes: an orange-and-black Cooperstown weekend

Voting results are scheduled for January 19, announced on an MLB Network broadcast beginning at 3 p.m. PT, per Yahoo Sports.

The New York Times frames the stakes in Giants terms: if Posey is elected on the first ballot, it would set up a black-and-orange-splashed induction weekend July 23-26, because Bruce Bochy, who managed those three title teams, and Brian Sabean, the GM who drafted Posey, are both under consideration by the Contemporary Baseball Era Committee — as is Dusty Baker, the winningest manager in Giants uniform.

Carlos Beltrán and Andruw Jones were elected on last year's ballot, per Yahoo Sports, so the 2027 class could pair fresh stars with returning names like the 14 first-timers that also include Jake Arrieta, Pablo Sandoval, Kyle Seager and Ryan Zimmerman.

Elsewhere: UCF women's soccer lands NCAA berth

Separately, UCF Athletics reports the Knights' women's soccer team earned an at-large berth to the NCAA Tournament, its second straight appearance and 24th all-time.

At 11-5-2 after a seventh-place Big 12 finish, unseeded UCF opens on the road against No. 5 seed Florida State, the defending national champion.

It is the program's seventh NCAA berth under 14-year head coach Tiffany Roberts Sahaydak, and UCF carries a 3-1-1 record against top-25 foes into the first round.

Sources

  1. nytimes.com › MLB Hall of Fame candidates announced: Will Buster Posey earn induction on first ballot?
  2. sports.yahoo.com › Chase Utley, first-timer Buster Posey headline 2027 Hall of Fame ballot
  3. ucfknights.com › Women's Soccer Earns At-Large Berth, Will Face Florida State in First-Round Matchup

More on Sports